This lecture is free for everyone, here on Substack, before it comes out on YouTube on Monday, October 12. Normally, paid members get episodes early. This one is open to all of you, a one-time open screening.
This lecture is about dark matter, and it teaches general relativity from scratch. The derivations are all on screen, so you can pause and check them.
Philip Mannheim is professor emeritus of physics at the University of Connecticut. He works on conformal gravity, an alternative to Einstein’s general relativity, and with James O’Brien he fit the rotation curves of 138 galaxies with no dark matter, using four universal parameters and adjusting only each galaxy’s mass-to-light ratio. For this lecture he prepared 164 pages of notes for the TOE audience, and all of their references are linked below.
This is Part One. Part Two is yet to come.
We cover:
General relativity built from scratch, up to the Einstein equations
Einstein, Poincaré, and who deserves credit for special relativity
Neptune, Vulcan, and the first success and first failure of dark matter theory
Why Philip says calling a theory “epicycles” is unfair to Ptolemy
Fitting versus overfitting, explained with real galaxy data
Why Philip calls the usual dark matter reasoning “somewhat circular”
The “neutrino fog,” and why dark matter particle searches may never settle it
A prediction Philip made in 2018, and the dwarf galaxy data that arrived in 2025
Are Einstein’s equations necessary, or only sufficient?
Sponsors
Visit mod.com for a free consultation and get 10% off your first order PLUS free shipping with promo code TOE.
Take Cheers Restore after your last drink or before going to bed and wake up feeling at least 50% better, or your money back. For a limited time our listeners are getting 20% off their entire order at cheershealth.com/TOE.
Lecture Notes
Philip’s 164-page lecture notes are free to download for every subscriber, free or paid.
Philip’s lecture notes are free for every subscriber.
Timestamps
00:00 - Three Dark Problems, One Cause?
08:31 - The 120-Order Cosmological Catastrophe
13:17 - Newton, Kepler, and Ptolemy
21:29 - Mercury's Anomalous Precession
27:20 - Neptune Found, Vulcan Vanished
34:12 - Galactic Rotation Curves
40:00 - Dwarf Galaxies Break Universality
45:48 - Where Are the WIMPs?
52:00 - Tully-Fisher: Galaxies Know
58:06 - Four Parameters, 138 Galaxies
01:06:00 - Milgrom's Law and the RAR
01:12:10 - Fourth-Order Poisson Equation
01:20:28 - Missing Mass in Plain Sight
01:26:13 - Confirmed Low-Acceleration Prediction
01:33:00 - Metrics From Scratch
01:39:00 - Why Einstein Changed Newton
01:44:31 - Riemann Tensor: Real Gravity
01:49:50 - Equivalence Principle Derived
01:55:00 - Building Einstein's Equations
02:00:54 - Light Bending and Ricci Flatness
02:07:45 - Are Einstein's Equations Unique?
Transcript
00:00:00 · Three Dark Problems, One Cause?
Philip: Dark matter doesn’t know. But the galaxies know. The data are telling you, “You have to do something to Newton.”
Curt: This is the legendary physicist Philip Mannheim, who’s spent decades developing conformal gravity, an alternative to Einstein’s general relativity. Just like our previous lecture, which went viral with Tim Maudlin, the professor was given an unlimited amount of time to get his point across with sufficient rigor and technicality so that you can pause and check the derivations for yourself. So what is the physical mechanism by which the local knows about the global?
Philip: The linear potential grows with distance. So the object which is the furthest away from you is putting out the largest potential.
Curt: This lecture is an explanation first of the dark matter problem, but also he teaches general relativity from scratch.
Philip: I find it absolutely staggering.
Curt: Much of this lecture is me being silent, partially because I’m saving questions for later, but primarily because it’s a masterful presentation. I’ve seen several lectures that span 20 lectures on this material, and he’s managed to place it all in one.
Philip: You don’t realize how many years this took.
Curt: For this lecture, Philip prepared a huge 164-page PDF just for the Theories of Everything audience, where he goes into all the gory detail that we like from the ground up, what conformal gravity is all about, and how it potentially solves various issues in theoretical physics.
Philip: You don’t have to accept the solution that I’ll present.
Curt: On this channel, I, Curt Jaimungal, interview researchers regarding their theories of reality with rigor and technical depth. Today, I’m thrilled to bring you part one of Philip Mannheim’s lecture.
Philip: So this theory is saying there never was a missing mass problem.
Curt: Professor, welcome. It’s such an honor to speak with you again after the huge viral hit of the previous conformal gravity episode.
Philip: Well, first of all, Curt, thank you very much for the previous invitation and also for the second kind invitation. In the talk I gave a few weeks ago, I saw a lot of comments. I’m going to try to respond to those comments in this presentation, but I’m also going to give a lot more of the details that I didn’t give last time. And there’s going to be some equations, and I have to apologize that some of them will be somewhat intensive.
Okay, so my title is “Why Are—Why There Are Dark Matter, Dark Energy, and Quantum Gravity Problems.”
Curt: Here’s the entire overview. Philip’s lectures cover eight topics. Today is the first three. So number one, the dark problems. That is dark matter, dark energy, and also quantum gravity, which are all problems Philip traces to a single source, where you stretch Newton and Einstein beyond the solar system, where they were tested.
Then number two, dark matter itself, Newton’s laws, where it works, where it breaks down, why there was the search for dark matter to begin with, what is the data, why second order is local, but fourth order is global, and what this all means, and how his conformal gravity fits this.
And then lastly, number three for this part, Einstein’s gravity from scratch. I’m so happy all of this is explained at the beginner level, metrics, geodesics, the Riemann tensor, all the way up to Einstein’s equations. And then a question that rarely comes up, which is, are those equations necessary? And are they even unique?
There are timestamps for all of these on screen and in the description. Skip around if you like. This is meant to be rewatched. So don’t concern yourself if you’re not following along. Okay, and just for the viewers who are wondering, yes, every resource mentioned here, such as the papers in the beginning, they will be in the description. Links to them will also be on the Substack, including this presentation. So curtjaimungal.com, C-U-R-T-J-A-I-M-U-N-G-A-L.com.
Philip: Okay, very good. Now, let’s begin with the dark matter problem. The dark matter problem is already 100 years old. Almost as soon it was realized that the Milky Way was a galaxy, which was not known till 1910 or so, in the 1920s, Oort found that the velocities of stars perpendicular to the plane of the galaxy, namely not in the disk, but perpendicular to the disk, were going too fast for all the—for the material that—the stars that he could see, and he identified a missing mass problem.
As soon as it was realized that there were other galaxies in the 1930s, Zwicky and then Smith found that the velocity dispersions of galaxies in a cluster of galaxies also had a missing mass problem, namely that the galaxies were going too quick.
Now, there were three possibilities for that—to explain that. One is there was more matter than one could see, that there was missing matter, which—and if you could not see it and eventually never could see it, it would become dark matter. There was a second issue is what—it said velocity dispersion because we have to apply the virial theorem, and that presupposes that there’s no correlation energy, that every galaxy is moving independently, and maybe that’s not true because that takes time, and maybe these clusters hadn’t had enough time to basically to thermalize. And the third, which they had recognized at the time, this possible breakdown of Newton’s law of gravity on large distance scales. This was already back in the 1930s.
In the 1970s, H I radio studies of Freeman and Roberts and Whitehurst. H I are the excitations of the two spin-up and spin-down states of the ground state of an atom, in particularly a hydrogen atom, and that’s the 21-centimeter line, which is in the radio, and those were studied by Freeman and Roberts and Whitehurst, and then subsequently Vera Rubin studied H II. H II is—hydrogen atoms that are very close to stars get a lot of radiation from those stars, and then they get optically excited, and that’s called H II. And Rubin, Ford, and Thonnard showed that—all of these people showed that the measured rotational velocities in the outskirts of a spiral galaxy greatly exceeded the luminous Newtonian expectation. And again, there was a missing mass problem. And then the dam broke with missing mass problems all the way up to cosmology and a brand-new problem to boot, dark energy.
Now, for dark matter, two possible astrophysical options. It’s faint, need better telescopes. That’s now been ruled out. And it could be dead. And we know there are certain very—stars that are no longer shining, have run out of nuclear fuel, black holes, white dwarfs, collectively known as massive compact halo objects, or MACHOs. Now, we’ve ruled this out because we can do gravitational lensing off the Magellanic Clouds, and I’ll come back to that in a few moments, but we now know that this is not the case.
Another possibility for dark matter is particles that are intrinsically unable to emit light. These objects, by virtue of not being able to emit light, tend not to clump the way black holes or white dwarfs, and so you get a diffuse background, possibly neutrinos, supersymmetric particles, axions, dark photons. They’re weakly interacting massive particles, and they’re known as WIMPs. So those are the two possibilities.
Extensive decades-long accelerator and underground searches have yet to find any WIMPs. Now, it’s not ruled out, but it’s far from being ruled in. And there is a tension for supersymmetry since no superparticles have been found at the LHC that could solve what’s called the elementary Higgs boson hierarchy problem. Namely, why is the Higgs boson that’s been found, why is it at 125 GeV and not up at some gigantic scale? And supersymmetry was—one of the things it would do was solve that, and it cannot have done that because we can’t say that there are no superparticles, but we can say that none have been found in the mass region where the Higgs boson has been found, namely 125 GeV.
00:08:31 · The 120-Order Cosmological Catastrophe
Philip: The dark energy problem is also 100 years old. This problem is also called the cosmological constant problem, and it was—became very severe after the 1998 discovery of the accelerating universe, which meant that you couldn’t live without some dark energy or cosmological constant in the standard theory. But the problem predates the accelerating universe. Einstein introduced the cosmological constant in the 1920s. So this problem is also 100 years old.
Now, if you take the current-era Hubble parameter, the value of it, and you calculate a quantity called omega lambda, which just involves this lambda, the cosmological constant, Newton’s constant, the velocity of light, and the Hubble parameter that we measure, the amount—that quantity is the amount by which the cosmological constant will gravitate today in the standard dark energy, cold dark matter cosmology, lambda, dark energy, CDM, cold dark matter.
Now, all estimates of this number put it of order at least 10^60 if it’s a TeV scale coming from the weak interaction, or 10^120 if it’s the Planck scale, h-bar c over G N to the half, coming from quantum gravity. And the data can never support anything more than omega lambda is 0.7. So if these numbers are correct, 10^60 or 10^120, none of the CMB, the cosmic microwave background, background or fluctuation tests would be successful. In fact, they would actually be some of the worst fits in the history of physics. They would be off by no less than 60 or 120 orders of magnitude. So that’s 100 years.
The quantum gravity problem is 70 years old. Even if you buy into the standard lambda CDM, lurking behind all of this is the hope that the standard Newton-Einstein classical gravity expectations are not destroyed by quantum mechanics. Now, you might think, “Well, quantum mechanics only acts on small scales like atoms,” but no. There are large-scale quantum effects. Quantum is microscopic. It’s not just microscopic. And we know that because we have to use the Pauli degeneracy of electrons in a white dwarf star, and it’s stable up to a certain mass called the Chandrasekhar mass, which you can see here depends exactly on Planck’s constant. It’s a quantum mechanical mass coming from the Pauli principle, which is quantum mechanical.
And the energy density, rho r, and the pressure P, rho by three, of the quantum mechanical cosmic microwave background itself is a black—it’s a macroscopic blackbody. It fills the entire universe, and it depends intrinsically on Planck’s constant. So we see already that there are quantum effects on the larger scales. And gravity acts on the larger scale, so gravity is fully aware of all of these effects.
Einstein gravity was developed by Einstein in 1915. Quantum field theory was developed by Dirac, Feynman, Schwinger, Tomonaga, and Dyson in the 1930s and ’40s. So the quantum gravity problem, namely making Einstein gravity consistent with quantum field theory, is more than 70 years old. So those are the problems.
Let’s just review. Three problems, dark matter, dark energy, quantum gravity. Continue Einstein gravity beyond its solar system origins to galaxies and clusters of galaxies, get the dark matter problem. To cosmology, get the dark energy and additional dark matter problems. Quantize, get the renormalization problem. So maybe we’ve got the wrong extrapolation of solar system wisdom. If so, could we solve all three problems at once? If a common cause, then possibly a common solution.
Now, you don’t have to accept the solution that I’ll present in this lecture. But you have to recognize the very fact that we can extrapolate. That’s the feature I’m going to explain shortly. How is it that there’s even the possibility of extrapolation? How is it even the possibility that something may have gone wrong from what we know about the solar system? And to expose that, I’m going to discuss the nature of the problem.
00:13:17 · Newton, Kepler, and Ptolemy
Philip: It’s gonna start with the solar system wisdom that we have. We’ve met two problems, more sources, existence of a planet called Neptune, or a new theory, and that was Einstein’s resolution of the motion of Mercury. Now, Newton’s law of gravity, very simple. F is ma. F is m times capital M, the source, G Newton divided by r squared, and a is a unit vector in the direction of the acceleration. This law recognizes an ordered phenomenon in nature. It’s universal. All systems use the same G Newton. For a motion of a particle falling towards the center of the Earth, the mass of the particle drops out, and Galileo’s law that all particles fall with the same acceleration is recovered.
Now, Newton was concerned that maybe the law should be F is m i times a, but F is m g times M G N over r squared times a, with the inertial mass here and the gravitational mass there, and then the mass would not drop out. Only if the masses drop out will we have the acceleration is independent of the mass of the particle. Now, this expression is remarkable because if we know G N, which was measured by Cavendish, we can determine the mass of the Earth and the mass of the Sun just by looking at this acceleration because it’s universal. It holds on all scales. Eötvös showed that m i and m g were equal, and this was a key signpost for Einstein in discovering his theory.
Now, for circular motion, we can write—Newton writes down v squared over r is M G over r squared, and the acceleration points toward the Sun. It’s like a ball on a string, but there’s no string. Now we get Kepler’s laws. The orbits are ellipses with the Sun at the focus of the ellipse. v squared falls like one over r. That’s called the Kepler law. Equal areas in equal times. T squared is four pi r cubed over M, the solar mass times G New... namely that the square of the time of an orbit is proportional to the cube of the radius of the orbit with the same number for every planet. And this replaces Ptolemy.
Now, let me say a few words about this. Ptolemy came up with a theory of the motion of the planets, and it has—based on circles, but circles within circles, and it had what we call epicycles. And when you want to prove a point to a bad theory, you always point to Ptolemy’s epicycles. And if you’re getting a theory which is starting to add on more and more and more things to make the previous one work, then we call this epicycles. But that’s very unfair to Ptolemy. Ptolemy wrote down a theory which lasted for 1,500 years before its errors accumulated to the point where you could actually see a problem.
In fact, Tycho Brahe noticed that there was a conjunction of Saturn and Jupiter which didn’t occur when Ptolemy said it was supposed to occur. And that’s a 1,500-year period. No theory in physics has lasted longer. Maybe the theories that we have today will still be around in another 1,000 years, but this is quite remarkable.
Now, how did Kepler come up with this law? Well, he started off with Ptolemy, and he said, “Well, I want to understand the orbit of Mars, and I want it to be a circle.” And he tried very hard, and it could not work. So the next step he thought was, “Well, let’s have a circle, but not have the velocity going round be uniform all the time.” And he came up with equal areas in equal times. That would—that’s the law for how the velocity must behave. This, by the way, we now understand is conservation of angular momentum, but nonetheless, that’s what he found.
And he realized that it wasn’t a circle, and it wasn’t uniform velocity. So what was it? And now Kepler has got one of the hardest problems that I think any person could ever have. If the orbit of Mars is not a circle—then he’s looking at Mars from the Earth, and therefore the orbit of the Earth must also not be a circle. It must be this unknown orbit which he’s trying to figure out. In other words, he has to figure out the orbit of Mars and the orbit of the Earth because he’s sitting on the Earth.
The way he does that is because he works in the system in which the Sun is the center of the solar system, and he comes up with an ellipse. Now, why is it an ellipse? And Newton shows that it is indeed an ellipse because if you just plot the potential, there are two pieces. There’s Newton’s one over r potential, and there’s the centrifugal barrier because the object is moving, and you plot this, and you get a curve, and therefore you sit. An orbit would move between these two points. And therefore, there’s a minimum point called perigee, and a close and a furthest point called apogee.
And therefore, you will have a circle which is... Sorry, you’ll have an ellipse which is not a circle, and the major axis will be bigger than the minor axis because that’s the—what you get from here. Now, the question that came up immediately is when you go round, you go all the way round, do you come back to the same place? Or all you have to do is move in here. You could come back here, you could come back there, and so on. You don’t have to exactly come back to the previous place. And it turns out that if the potential were not one over r, you would not come back to the same place. There would be what’s called precession. But with the one over r potential, there is no precession, and therefore you come back to that place again.
Curt: Theories of Everything is brought to you by Mod. Mod prescribes a once- or twice-daily modafinil drink that can keep you energized, focused, and alert throughout the day. The mechanism is that energy drinks come with caffeine, which temporarily block adenosine, and that’s a chemical that makes you feel tired, and that builds up. When the caffeine wears off, you just crash. But modafinil, the mechanism here is different. It engages multiple pathways in your brain, dopamine, norepinephrine, histamine, and orexin, to achieve steady energy and alertness for up to 10 to 12 hours.
Modafinil was invented in the 1970s, and since then it’s been used by the highest performers on and off the planet. Soldiers, pilots, astronauts even, aboard the space station use modafinil in high-stakes situation where full concentration and alertness are paramount. It’s now available at mod.com to qualifying patients. Visit mod.com, that’s M-O-D.com, for a free consultation and get 10 percent off your first order, plus free shipping with promo code TOE. That’s promo code TOE at mod.com. See their website for important safety information, and we thank Mod for sponsoring the pod.
00:21:29 · Mercury's Anomalous Precession
Philip: And of course, people knew that the planet Mercury did not come back to the same place. Now, why... What’s the big deal about Mercury? Mercury was the planet that was closest to the Sun, and therefore it does three orbits in the time that the Earth does one orbit. And in watching it over 100 years, you’re looking at 300 years—300 orbits, and so any error would accumulate.
All planets will undergo some precession, but only Mercury is good enough that we have enough data for long enough to have been able to measure it. Planets out in the edge of the solar system, like Neptune, have yet to complete one single orbit since it was discovered. We have yet to see it go all the way around once. But nonetheless, it does happen that for one over r, this axis, the major axis, does not move, and that’s called the Runge-Lenz vector. And we’ll come back to that in a while because that’s what enabled Heisenberg and Pauli to solve the energy levels of the hydrogen atom by the existence of this second invariance.
Okay. But you can see that there are the two foci, and the immediate question you ask is, “Well, what’s the other focus? What’s so special about this particular focus?” Well, the answer is that all the planets have the same common focus. So this, let’s say the blue orbit, there’s the second focus. The red orbit, there’s the second focus. So the second focus is not common to all of the planets, or to all of the orbits, but the one where the Sun is, is the one which is common.
So we can think of the Sun, and we can think of arms connecting out to the distant stars. Now, unlike swinging a ball, there are no strings attached. So we don’t see the connection between the Sun and the planets. It’s called action at a distance. And we now understand from electromagnetism that two charges can interact with each other by exchanging photons. And so for gravity, we have this idea that they exchange gravitons as a way of communicating. And the force is a non-contact force, and there are no strings attached.
Now, if these strings had only been visible and they were all radiating out from the Sun, it would have been obvious to the ancients that the Sun was the center of the solar system. That it took many, many generations to figure it out was simply that the strings are invisible, and we need to go to quantum theory in order to get them visible. That’s the wisdom of the solar system, and I should just state again, Kepler figured this out before the invention of the telescope and before the invention of calculus. Namely, it was just naked-eye observations plotting meticulously night after night after night the positions of all of the planets.
Now, is it for sure that Kepler would have done so? Well, it turns out that there’s an accident. We are not the only planet in the solar system. There are other planets to compare with. If it had happened that the Earth was the only planet in the solar system, it would have been very hard to extract out an orbit of the Earth. And so we’re just very lucky that there are all these other planets as well.
Now, the presence of other planets is crucial for another reason. We always say that we—that the Earth doesn’t go around... The Sun doesn’t go around the Earth, the Earth goes around the Sun. That’s completely meaningless. There are two objects in orbit around each other, and whether you want to say one goes around the other or A goes around B or B goes around A, it doesn’t mean anything. It only becomes a meaning because there’s a third object, and that third object is going around the Sun and not around the Earth.
And so you don’t... If you have the Sun, the Earth, and one other planet, it’s not true that the Sun and the other planet are going around the Earth. It’s the two planets, the planet and the Earth itself, that are going around the Sun, and that’s the thing that gives meaning to, is the Earth going around the Sun or is the Sun going around the Earth? It only becomes defined because there’s another planet to act as a reference.
Okay. So now let’s look at the solar system. We do what Kepler tells us. We plot the velocity as a function of distance, and this is an absolutely fantastic curve. v goes like one over r to the half. Now, if you notice, the Earth, it’s the third one in, we’re going 30 kilometers per second. If you just take the radius of the Earth, two pi r, the circumference, divide by the time it takes, a year, you’ll come up with this number, 30 kilometers per second.
And we have no sense that this is happening, and that’s what held up understanding the laws of motion because we don’t feel this motion even though it’s occurring.
00:27:20 · Neptune Found, Vulcan Vanished
Philip: Now, the planets laid in this curve, and there were two problems with it. Up to Mercury, Venus, Earth, Mars, Jupiter, and Saturn, those were the naked eye. They were known to the ancients. With the invention of the telescope, Uranus was discovered, and it was found that it was slightly off the curve. It was guessed that maybe there’s yet another planet, one called Neptune, that was just perturbing it just a little bit to push it off this curve. Neptune had not been seen, so it would go under the name—to... In modern language, we’d say it was dark matter. However, it was eventually seen because, now, if you got a better telescope, Neptune doesn’t emit light, but it reflects light back from the Sun. And so with the better telescope, Neptune was discovered, and this was the very first success of dark matter theory, where a dark matter object was postulated and then it was discovered.
I’m sorry to have to say that up till now it’s been the only success of dark matter theory. It’s the only dark matter object that we’ve so far identified. Now, what about the inner system? Well, Mercury was also off the scale as well. I mentioned a moment ago there was this precession. Mercury was also off the scale, and it was proposed that there was another planet, just like we did with Neptune, there was another planet pulling on Mercury called Vulcan. And Vulcan was looked for, but the inner solar system, it’s hard to hide because it’s so well-studied, and it became clear that Vulcan was not there.
Curt: A quick question about that.
Philip: Yes.
Curt: Mercury’s orbit is not just odd because it’s off of this chart. It also has that perihelion like you mentioned.
Philip: No, no, the perihelion that puts it off the chart. Yes. I’m going to explain that in a moment. So it’s not quite on the chart. People proposed another planet was pulling it, just like the Neptune solution. People were able to categorically explore the inner solar system and say, “No, there is no Vulcan.” And this was the first recorded failure of dark matter theory. Here was a dark matter particle that had to exist and was shown not to.
Now, but—so Vulcan goes away, but Mercury is still off the scale, and therefore something has to be done about Newton’s law of gravity. Now, let me just go back a moment ago and remind, as long as it’s one over r, you come back to the same place as before. But this time it wasn’t doing that. So there was some modification to one over r. And that modification was discovered by Einstein, and it’s a one over r cubed correction, and it exactly explains the precession of Mercury, namely the degree to which it doesn’t go round in a closed ellipse.
So nice as this was, Mach in the 19th century is very concerned about the following. You just take Newton’s law of motion in free space, x double dot is zero, and that’s called an inertial frame. Set x prime is x plus a half gt squared, evaluate x prime double dot and it’s g, which is then called a non-inertial frame. And so you have an acceleration—you have acceleration here, and you have no acceleration there. And Mach felt there was something seriously wrong with this, and what he proposed was that the local physical laws are determined by the large-scale structure of the universe, namely the interaction of local and global physics will tell us whether we should be using this one or that one.
Now, it turns out that in that regard, Mach was completely wrong. The—this is not the reason why we have inertial frames. However, that there is an interaction with the—between us and the large-scale structure of the universe, that he got right, and we’ll see why in a moment. So we have this inertial force. We can move it in, and we can move it out. Is it real, or is it a fake? That was the problem that Einstein solved.
Now, it doesn’t have to just apply to gravity. If we take x double dot is zero, and we just set x prime is x times some function of x, y, z, and t, arbitrary function, then we get x double dot prime is two x dot f dot plus x f double dot, so it’s not zero. And the reason is this is a nonlinear transformation.
This is also a nonlinear transformation because it goes like t squared, not like t, and these equations are not left invariant under nonlinear transformations, and that was Mach’s concern. So now let’s look at this. What was the achievement of Newton? The law of gravity is universal. We only need to know the luminous matter distribution, i.e., the Sun, with v squared over r is M solar G N over r squared. With one parameter, the mass of the Sun, we fix the orbits of all the planets. This is the Newtonian gold standard. If we like this, which we do, you would want to have the same thing happen for galaxies. With dark matter, you do not get the Newtonian gold standard, as we’ll see in a moment.
Newton proves a theorem. To determine the force at any given point on a spherical surface in a spherical distribution, you only need the matter interior to the spherical surface. The reason is the force falls like one over r squared, while the solid angle grows like r squared, so they cancel. Thus, Newtonian gravity is local. Therefore, whenever there might be a problem, you need to introduce more sources, and you need to put them where the problem is. You can’t put the problem outside because it would decouple. And if you can’t see any sources, you have—they have to be invisible, and that becomes dark matter.
Now, we can’t rule in or rule out dark matter by astrophysical measurements alone, but we can analyze astrophysical data to see the challenge that they raise to dark matter.
00:34:12 · Galactic Rotation Curves
Philip: To see what that challenge is, let’s look for clues from the data. Focus on galactic rotation curves of spirals, since no theory is needed, just orbits.
This is a spiral galaxy, and you can see the beautiful spiral arms, and you can see there’s a clear orbital pattern. Now, this is a galaxy that’s—we’re looking at face-on, and so the velocity will be along the tangent and will never reach us, so we can never measure face-on galaxies. But what we can do is we can look at a galaxy which is edge-on, because an edge-on galaxy, one side will be coming towards us, and the other side would be going away from us, and the sum of the two velocities is the overall flow of the galaxy, which we now call the Hubble flow, and the difference is the rotation velocity.
Now, this picture is actually a picture of the Milky Way as seen by somebody on Andromeda. Now, of course, nobody in Andromeda has ever sent us a picture of the Milky Way. What happens is there’s a NASA satellite that goes round and round, and it goes one orbit around the Earth in an hour and a half, and the Earth itself is going around the solar system, and the solar system is going around the Milky Way at 200 kilometers per second. Remember, the Earth is going round the Sun at 30 kilometers per second, but the Sun itself is going much, much faster. And so we get a good scan of the Milky Way.
Now, of course, we really know what the other galaxies look like to guess that this is what ours must look like. Now, let’s suppose, since I’ve got this picture, let’s suppose that we’re surrounded by dark matter. Then if we look at a distant object, and the one that we—you don’t see it on the picture, but there’s a—the Milky Way has two satellite galaxies called the Magellanic Clouds, the small and the large. And if there’s dark matter here, and we’re looking at these clouds, when the dark matter object goes by, we will see some lensing or some modification of the light, and we don’t see any. And so we’re able to conclude that there’s no dark matter between us and the Magellanic Clouds.
Now, it turns out that when the experiments were first done, they started to see some of these dark objects suddenly block the field of view. But it turns out that the dark objects themselves were also in the Magellanic Cloud. And also, when people looked in the plane of the galaxy, they found a large number of dead stars called white dwarfs, which they didn’t know about. And from that, we learned that, in fact, the Milky Way has a bar down the center, that the Milky Way is a barred spiral. So it’s very interesting. The realization that the Milky Way is a barred spiral came because of a very specific property of Einstein gravity. And this is one of the reasons why people are so confident it’s correct.
Curt: Let’s look at the chemistry behind Cheers Restore, starting with how your body makes glutathione. People tell me the same two drinks hit harder at 40 than they do at 22. The reason is glutathione, often called the body’s master antioxidant. Glutathione drifts down as you age, and processing alcohol draws it down further, and your body leans on it to handle acetaldehyde. That’s the byproduct that your liver turns alcohol into, which is actually more toxic than the alcohol itself. A small reserve of this glutathione, but yet you have the same demand. So your body builds its own from cysteine.
Cheers Restore contains L-cysteine, which also binds to acetaldehyde directly, plus DHM, a flavonoid from the Japanese raisin tree. There’s no proprietary blends. Take it after your last drink or before bed. Cheers says you’ll feel at least 50 percent better or your money back. For a limited time, go to cheershealth.com slash TOE and use code TOE for 20 percent off your entire order. That’s Cheers, C-H-E-E-R-S health.com slash TOE. This video is sponsored by Cheers.
Philip: Now, if you look at this picture, what we’re seeing in the visible region, that’s the H II, that’s the ionized hydrogen atoms. But there’s also material out here that you don’t see. It’s hydrogen atoms that have not yet been processed into stars. And so we can see out there, and that will give us a much better handle on the velocities at large distances. So this is the distribution of the visible matter, and that’s the distribution of the non-processed gas. We study this in the optical, and the region where we see it is called the optical disk, and we study this region in the radio. And so as far as we can see out in the radio, we can see the velocities of the various stars or the various material.
And now we look, here’s the optical region, there’s the luminous material. Therefore, that is what Kepler would tell us should happen. That’s what Newton tells us should happen.
00:40:00 · Dwarf Galaxies Break Universality
Philip: Once we get outside the visible distribution, namely once we’re out here, once we get outside, this velocity has to fall. But what’s seen is the velocity doesn’t fall. And for a bright spiral like NGC 3198, the velocity is almost flat. It’s almost constant from the inner region to the outer region. And so the piece that’s missing, add it in, the piece that’s missing isn’t flat, the piece that’s missing must be rising.
Now, what about another galaxy called DDO 154? This is a dwarf, and you can tell there’s a dwarf. You can see this is 150 kilometers per second, whereas this is only 40 to 50 kilometers per second, which is much smaller. So the velocities are much smaller. But now what you see again is that the—here’s the Newton piece coming from the gas. And what you see is again the curve is rising.
But now let’s look at the shortfall. The difference between the actual velocity and the one you get from Newton is a factor of two. Two in the velocity is four in v squared. But in the dwarf, the difference is a factor of three. And so in v squared, it’s a factor of nine. In other words, in a bright spiral, if you want to explain this by dark matter, the dark to luminous ratio is going to be three or four to one. In a dwarf, the ratio is going to be eight or nine to one.
Therefore, the thing that we infer from this is twofold. One, whatever is going on here is not like Mercury. It’s not a very, very small correction. Mercury, in fact, was one part in 10^8. What it is, is an effect of order one. The effect is as big as the Newton piece. And so we see this a very large effect. And we also see it’s not universal because that’s a ratio of two and that’s a ratio of three. So how do you fix it? How do you fix things up? Well, you assume dark matter.
Now, you need dark matter where there’s little luminous matter, which means you need it out here where you can’t see it. That’s why it’s called dark. It’s not a small effect. It’s a very big effect, and it’s not universal. The dark to luminous ratio is not universal. The bright spiral curves are flat. The dwarfs are rising. The case where dark matter dominates, namely the largest dark to luminous ratio, is not rotation curves that are flat. It’s rotation curves that are rising because you already need dark matter here in the inner region.
So if you look at the bright spirals, the inner region up to this peak is completely described by Newton and the visible matter. But in the dwarfs, even in the inner region, something is going on. So the dwarfs are actually a bigger clue. Now... And the universal thing is that in all cases, the piece that’s missing is rising, and I’ll show you in a moment that it’s rising universally.
Curt: Can you explain that again about the dwarfs? Because I wasn’t able to see where your cursor was.
Philip: Ah, so I’m sorry. This is the luminous Newtonian expectation, and that’s the measured velocity. And you can see even in the smallest region, the measured velocity is much larger than the luminous expectation over here. Whereas in the bright spiral, there’s no problem. The dark matter is not contributing substantially in the inner region. So if you want to say it, if you look at a bright spiral, you can say the inner region is Newtonian. But you can’t say that of the dwarfs. And so the dwarfs are creating a new problem, which is not just apparent in the bright spiral.
Okay. Now, how do we make dark matter halo fits for the bright spirals? We need two free parameters per halo. The most standard one in Lambda CDM is the Navarro-Frenk-White dark matter profile, but it only gives the shape of the halo. Now, the isothermal sphere, which is a very straightforward and a popular one, also only gives the shape, and it contains two parameters, rho zero and r zero. And why do you need two parameters? Because in order to match the dark matter out here, you could have the dark matter up there, you could have the dark matter down there, but no, you need to max it—you need to match it to the luminous velocity.
But that only matches it here. But what about all the way in? Well, the dark matter could care—could fall, or it could rise. But you need it to stay constant, so for that, you need another parameter. And thus, if you want to do a dark matter fit to these rotation curves, you always need two free parameters. I’m going to discuss in a moment 138 well-studied galaxies, and that means dark matter needs 276 free dark matter halo parameters.
00:45:48 · Where Are the WIMPs?
Philip: Now, that’s already a challenge for dark matter, but now let’s look at the search for dark matter. The search for dark matter, as I mentioned before, the MACHOs and the WIMPs, you hope to see these objects, like I mentioned, between the Milky Way and the Large Magellanic Clouds, but it’s—the—that you can say that they’re not seen. On the other hand, the WIMPs, you have two chances. Remember, let’s just look at this again, we are already in a region where there’s a large amount of dark matter. So if we’re in this region with—where there’s a large amount of dark matter, dark matter must be in this—in the Milky Way. It must be in the solar system. So can we catch it? We will look to search underground, and we’ll also to see if we can produce it, namely in an accelerator.
So let’s see how that looks. This is the Large Hadron Collider. It’s the world’s largest and most powerful accelerator. This is the detection region, and that’s a person. You can see how big this is. And they’ve looked for supersymmetry. It’s called SUSY, supersymmetry. And these bands are the excluded zones. So they’ve looked at zillions of different processes, and always, this is the bad news, we never found any supersymmetry. And this goes up, these scales go up to 2,000 GeV, 2,000 times the mass of the proton. And the Higgs boson is around here at 125, so this is eight times the mass of the Higgs. So that’s the one group. Now this is a second group, and then yet a third group trying every imaginable channel, and never has supersymmetry shown up. In fact—
Curt: Now, quick question.
Philip: Yes.
Curt: Is there a reason to expect supersymmetry around the mass of the Higgs?
Philip: Yes.
Curt: Why can’t someone who’s still a proponent of supersymmetry just say, “Well, look, it wasn’t... Sure, we designed the LHC to find supersymmetry. We did not, but it’s okay because we could just bound the mass at a higher energy”?
Philip: Okay. The problem with supersymmetry is we never know the mass scale. You can build accelerators to explore new regions where you hope that maybe you will find supersymmetry. But there was one role that supersymmetry was going to play, and that was that it was going to stabilize the mass of the Higgs boson. And so from the beginning, it was not known when the LHC was built, it wasn’t known what the mass of the Higgs boson was going to be. But they found it at 125, and therefore they were always going to look for supersymmetry in that mass region. So this is where you would want it to be.
Now, if it’s not there, which it isn’t, it doesn’t exclude supersymmetry, but it does leave you with this problem of the Higgs boson mass. And I will come back to that later by showing you that it doesn’t have to be elementary. And if it’s not elementary, that problem goes away. But for the moment, that’s the challenge for supersymmetry.
Now, the underground searches, there’s a huge neutrino background coming at us from cosmic rays, from the Sun, and from the atmospheric neutrinos produced in the Earth’s atmosphere. And so we have to design an apparatus. This one is not quite so big as the LHC. We have to bury it underground to shield everything that’s coming in. And this red line here is the exclusion zone. Everything above this red line has been excluded. No WIMP of any description has ever been found. This is yet another search. The black line is the exclusion zone. And the last one that we have is called the LUX-ZEPLIN detector. And again, there’s no sign of any possible WIMP.
Now, that doesn’t mean that we won’t find them, but we’re now in a very awkward position. We’re very close to what’s called the neutrino fog. And that is that neutrinos are getting into the detector to a degree that we can no longer exclude them. Because as we push these bounds down, the stray neutrinos become more problematic. And it’s called a fog because it’s not excluded, but we need, essentially we need better detectors than we have at the moment if we’re able to monitor the neutrinos and hope that when we’ve got rid of the neutrinos that maybe some WIMPs will show up. So we’re in not good shape in terms of these underground searches because we’re pushing the limits on what we can do.
The accelerator searches were also not in good shape because we’ve got as far as we can in terms of energy. There’s an upgrade to the LHC which is going to improve luminosity. So if a WIMP was appearing one time in 10 billion and we were only previously able to measure one time in one billion, we may have a chance to see it. But beyond that, we’d need a new machine. We’d need to go to a higher energy. And whether or not governments are going to be amenable to do that remains to be seen.
So we may be coming into a very frustrating situation where we are technologically constrained by the underground searches and by the accelerator searches that we can’t really nail it down one way or the other. So we would be left in this frustrating situation of never being able to say yes and never being able to say no.
00:52:00 · Tully-Fisher: Galaxies Know
Philip: Now, difficulties for dark matter theory. We’ve just seen so far the difficulties for dark matter experiments, that we haven’t found any. Dark matter theory. Dark matter parameters are not derived from dark matter theory. Only the shapes are. So dark matter does not know which halo goes with which galaxy. So basically it’s just a parameterization of the data. And the parameters of the dark matter are only fixed after you’ve measured the velocities. Thus, a dark matter theorist needs the velocities in order to determine how much dark matter there is.
Now, given what we know about the solar system, what we would prefer is you, the observer, show me the luminous distribution, and I, the theorist, will tell you the velocity. That’s the Newtonian gold standard. And that is not yet met by dark matter theory. The reasoning is somewhat circular. You find that the luminous prediction does not work for galaxies. So you invent dark matter and then claim the fits as evidence for dark matter. And of course that’s not scientifically sound. So dark matter theory at the moment does not know how to match any halo that it produces with any given luminous distribution. Dark matter doesn’t know. But the galaxies know because the galaxies obey what’s called the Tully-Fisher relation.
And the Tully-Fisher relation says that if you plot the fourth power of the velocity against the luminosity, the visible material, it’s almost a straight line. Namely, the velocity to the four divided by the mass is universal. Now the velocity is the full gravitational potential, and it’s correlated with the luminous distribution. Thus, to get Tully-Fisher, you’d need the dark to luminous ratio to be universal as well. So then you could say v to the four over dark matter is universal. But I just showed you that the dark to luminous ratio is not universal. Therefore, it’s very hard for dark matter to explain the Tully-Fisher relation.
Now, in Newtonian gravity, we have v squared over r goes like MG over r squared. So it looks like v squared is growing like the mass rather than v to the four is going like the mass, which is telling you something else has to be going on. So the first important universal regularity is the Tully-Fisher relation. And so now let’s look at our sample to see if we can find any other relations that are universal. And so I looked at v squared over c squared r, the centripetal acceleration divided by the square of the speed of light at the last data point. Let me show you.
Look at all these... These are galaxies. The galaxies that I’m talking about, this sample, are done in surveys. The first survey had 18 galaxies in it, which was called the H I Nearby Galaxy Survey. The second one was half of the Ursa Major galaxy sample. There were—this is 15 out of the 30, and that’s another 30—another 15. Then there are the low surface brightness galaxies. These were pioneered by Vera Rubin and Stacy McGaugh. And you can see, I just should have mentioned that in every case, the Newton piece is falling short, and there’s this curve that’s going through all the data. And let me only tell you that that is going to be the conformal gravity fit.
And so we have a second LSB sample. Then another sample, these 22 galaxies, these are very big ones. You can see here velocities as high as 300 kilometers per second. These were the first galaxies that were ever explored in which people realized that there was a serious problem, the so-called missing mass problem. And now we’ve got a dwarf sample. These are the small galaxies. You can see the dwarfs because these numbers here, these are just 60 or so kilometers per second. Again, same story. Same story. Second dwarf sample of the 24, that’s the 138. Oh, and then there was this other six.
And then finally, let me look—let me show you v squared over c squared r at the last data point. And those are the numbers. Now, these two are a little bit high because they’re not yet asymptotic. They don’t go out as far, but they’re all clustering around a certain value, 10^-30 inverse centimeters. Let’s go to the next group. Same story. Let me go to the next group. Same story. Let me go to the second LSB sample. Same story. Let me go to the miscellaneous sample. Same story. Let me go to the dwarfs. Same story.
What we’re finding is that the—at the last data point, v squared over c squared r is almost universal. It’s the same in every galaxy, but these galaxies vary in luminosity by factors of 1,000. These—they have different morphology. They’re different galaxies. But these numbers all come out the same.
00:58:06 · Four Parameters, 138 Galaxies
Philip: And James O’Brien and I found that we could parameterize the entire 138 data points with a formula which only involve beta star, gamma star, gamma zero, and kappa, four numbers, and N star is the amount of visible material.
So N star is the visible mass. Beta star is what we usually call MG over c squared. That’s the Schwarzschild radius of the Sun. Gamma star is one new number, which is much smaller. Gamma zero, you—has to be 10^-30 inverse centimeters. Why? Because if v squared goes like gamma zero c squared r over two, then divide by c squared and divide by r. V squared over c squared r goes like gamma zero, therefore gamma zero must be this particular number. And then there is this kappa term, which is a little bit smaller.
Curt: I’d like to jump in for a moment because the last time when you were explaining that 138 so-and-so have been fit, some of the viewers, they hear the word “fit,” and they have an allergic reaction to the word “fit.” But that’s because they think that that means you’ve tuned something or fine-tuned something, but that’s overfitting. There’s a difference between fitting and overfitting.
Philip: It’s—
Curt: So can you please explain that?
Philip: Yes. Okay. I’ve only got four free parameters, so I can fix that from four galaxies. Then I’ve got to do the other 134. I mean, it’s exactly what you did for the solar system. You fixed the mass of the Sun by the orbit of the Earth, and now you know the mass of the Sun. You’ve got the orbits of all the other galaxy—of all the other planets. So you want... However you want to use the word, you have to say you are fitting all of the orbits of all of the galaxies, or you’re fitting one and predicting the others.
And so since I’ve only got four parameters, I’ve got 4,000 data points, and I’ve only got four parameters. And those numbers work for all of them, not just for one or two of them. They work for all of them. So that’s what I mean by “fit.” Now, the interesting thing is that this number is cosmological. The Hubble radius is around 10^28 centimeters, and this number is very, very close to the Hubble radius, so it’s a cosmological scale. And this number here is what’s called a cluster of galaxy scale. This is the—well, the square root of this is the typical size of a cluster of galaxies.
What about N star? Well, the fits got mass to light ratios because we measure the luminosity and we determine N star, so it’s N star over L, and they’re typical of the local solar neighborhood. Namely, they look just like the stars that are very, very close to us. And so we see this pattern. Gamma zero is cosmological. Kappa is a cluster of galaxy scale. Now, what makes this formula so interesting is that when you go to small r, all of these other terms become negligible because these coefficients are so small. And therefore, you come back to Newton’s law for the solar system, and you don’t get any departure from Newton in the solar system itself.
Now, in dark matter theory, you have to ask, “How does dark matter know it’s not supposed to mess up the solar system?” If there’s dark matter in the solar system, because if there wasn’t, we wouldn’t be looking for it. So how does it know that it’s only supposed to be relevant on galactic scales? I mean, I’m just saying is that’s one of the things that dark matter has to do. Now—
Curt: You’ve been arguing this since at least 2011, as you can see here. So what do the dark matter theorists say when they encounter this?
Philip: I pointed out before that dark matter can fit all of these rotation curves with two free parameters per halo, so 276 more parameters. And the dark matter people are contented with that. I don’t think they should be, but I’m stating to you that they’re contented with that. There are three theories that people have been promoting. My own theory, conformal gravity, Mordehai Milgrom’s MOND theory, modified Newtonian dynamics, and John Moffat’s MOG theory, modified gravity. And all of us do these—fit these rotation curves with universal parameters. And the reason that we do so is because the universal parameters are in the data. So the job of the dark matter theorist is to come up with these numbers.
Now, I’m afraid that they haven’t. And I’m afraid that for the moment, I mean, Milgrom was already doing this long before me. He started this in 1984. And they’ve never really responded to the economical formula that MOND is or the economical formula that conformal gravity or MOG is. Okay.
Curt: Why do you think that is?
Philip: Because they like what they’re doing. I don’t—look, how can I say this? If you start out by saying that Newton-Einstein holds on all distance scales and not just on the solar system scale, then you’re forced to dark matter. And then you do a lot of work, and it’s very clever work. I mean, it’s not—they’re not messing around. They do some very, very clever work to make dark matter work. And as long as they’re able to do that, they have no reason to go beyond it. But the data are saying, “Look,” the data are telling you there’s universality in the data. And that’s a clue. The Tully-Fisher relation is a clue. This formula is a clue. These numbers are clues. And it’s reasonable for dark matter to explain it.
This formula that I’ve just shown you here has not been shown—doesn’t follow from dark matter, and it challenges it. And it embodies distance scales, namely cosmological and cluster scales, that are relevant to Lambda CDM. And not only that, not only does this formula not involve any dark matter, it’s just N star, the visible material in the galaxy. And so it meets the Newtonian gold standard. If you are in the dark matter camp, you have to say, “We like Newton’s law of motion—law of gravity, but we don’t want that. We don’t care that it’s not being used universally the way that it’s being used in the solar system.” That you’re not doing the Newtonian gold standard.
Okay. Now, let me just show you in a picture. This is the observed acceleration as a function of the mass of each of these galaxies. And you can see it’s the log. So it’s going from about 10^8 to 10^12. And they all cluster in a very small region, as I just mentioned. In fact, you can take every data point in the entire set, which is around 4,000 data points. And again, they don’t show a radical departure. They live in a very narrow range.
Now, another thing you can do is you can plot g obs, the observed acceleration, versus the Newtonian acceleration.
01:06:00 · Milgrom's Law and the RAR
Philip: And if Newton were correct, luminous Newton were correct, you’d be on the red line. And you can see that the data get pulled slightly beyond that line. This is just the end points, the last data points. Now, McGaugh, Lelli, and Schombert realized that you could do all of the data points on a single graph.
Now, this is very important because I show you each rotation curve, but I have to show you 138 different graphs. Can we put all of the data points on one graph? That’s what they did. And I followed it up with O’Brien and Chiarelli shortly after. You plot g obs versus g new. The observed versus the luminous Newtonian expectation is called the radial acceleration relation. Now, the sample that O’Brien, Chiarelli, and myself looked at had 217—207 galaxies with 5,791 data points.
Now, how do we determine the g Newton? Well, I showed you before that the surface brightness of the luminous disk falls like an exponential, and if you integrate the one over r potential over that exponential, you’d not be surprised, you get Bessel functions.
Curt: Those are the modes of a disk?
Philip: Because those are the modes of a disk. And so you have that expression. Milgrom introduced a theory called MOND, and this is the MOND formula. And what you notice is that it’s designed to do various things. One is that asymptotically, you get v to the four over r squared goes like a zero m star beta star. Namely, v to the four goes to a constant, and it’s proportional—is v to the four proportional to N star, which is Tully-Fisher.
So the MOND formula, which only has one free parameter called the universal acceleration, let me write it out. It’s 10^-10 meters per second. And if you divide by c squared, it’s what we had before, namely 10^-30. It’s the same as that gamma zero I introduced a moment ago. And that’s the MOND formula that Milgrom developed. And McGaugh, Lelli, and Schombert made a slightly different formula as well, which we’ll call the MLS formula, and now you see what happens. You plot the observed against the Newton, and this green dotted line, that’s McGaugh, Lelli, and Schombert, and the brown line is Milgrom. And they go right through the center of the data. And these—this is the real world.
These are—this is not—there’s nothing invented here. This is just what the data look like. And this curve here, if it stayed on the red line, then there’d be no need for dark matter. So this is their curve, and—
Curt: Wait, so what have you discovered?
Philip: What have we discovered? Milgrom had said that departures from the luminous Newtonian expectation begin at around 10^-10, an acceleration of 10^-10 meters per second per second, and you see it. Above that point, everything agrees with Newton. Below that point, the data start to veer off, and that is a true law of nature. I call it Milgrom’s law. It really is true that the departures from luminous Newtonian expectation begin when the acceleration falls below a zero.
You may not like modified dynamics because that’s a formula for how the theory behaves when you drop below that a zero. I’m not saying you shouldn’t like it, but I’m saying is that there is an a zero is really independent of how the theory behaves below it. It also says, and this is what this says, is that the observed is correlated with the luminous Newtonian, and that is the Newtonian gold standard. No reference to dark matter. You can determine the obs if you have—if you just use, let’s say, this formula or this formula. You tell me the luminous distribution, I’ll get the Newtonian expectation, and I’ll tell you what is the measured acceleration. That’s exa... This is just as close as we can possibly get to what we’ve already got for the solar system. So you’ll see it in MOND. I’ll show you in a moment, you’ll see it in conformal gravity, and it also occurs in a Theory of Everything podcaster John Moffat’s MOG theory.
Curt: Good plug. Thank you.
Philip: Yes. Well, it has to be theories, so I have to mention more than one person.
Curt: Editor’s note, I have an extremely comprehensive catalog of the so-called crisis in physics on my Substack. The link is on screen, but also you can just go to curtjaimungal.com to find it. It’s probably the most exhaustive overview anywhere of sides that support the crisis and then sides that counter it, and then the counter to the counters, and the counter to those counters, and so forth. In fact, if you’ll allow a little plug, the Substack is a place where we go deeper, and I share my opinions on various aspects, various theories, various concepts, and people seem to be enjoying it.
And this guy here, Devin, says, “Dude, I can’t stop reading. Keep this up. You’re providing insights which are extremely relatable at the human experience level.” This other person says, “This was such beautiful writing. It made me tear up. Such amazing connections were drawn.” Science With Serena said that she appreciates how this is fun to read and you hardly notice the learning, and there are countless more. So feel free to go to curtjaimungal.com and subscribe. It’s a free newsletter. You often get the episodes early there as well. Okay, let’s get back to the episode.
Philip: So MLS, is it true? Is it a law of nature? Because it’s hard to see why it shouldn’t be a law of nature, but there is a width. So the question is, is there a width, or is it just you just go right down the middle? And then what happens when you go even further?
Philip: So let’s—we’ll see—we’ll examine that in a moment.
01:12:10 · Fourth-Order Poisson Equation
Philip: To see where this law might come from, we look at an open issue in gravity theory, the lack of necessity of the second-order Poisson equation. If you take del squared phi equals rho, the solution is minus constant over r. You take del four phi equals rho, the solution is constant over r plus a second constant times r. Del six phi over rho, minus constant over r plus a linear term plus a cubic term. The second-order Poisson equation is sufficient to give Newton’s law of gravity, but not necessary. One over r appears in all of these cases.
Now, in all of these cases, for small enough r, you come back to one over r. That’s for the solution, but not the equations. There’s no equation. There’s no limit in which del four becomes del squared or del six becomes del four becomes del squared. You only get the solutions will continue into each other, but not the equations. But to fit data, we only need to recover the solutions to a given theory such as Newton-Einstein, not the equations.
If you assume the second-order Poisson equation to be necessary, which means that this then holds out to all r, you’re forced to the dark matter problem, as it has to be second order on distances much larger than the solar system where Newton derived it. I’ll show you in a moment that not only is this true of the non-relativistic theory, but the conformal gravity theory is going to give us a fourth-order Poisson equation, and Einstein gives a second-order Poisson equation, and the fourth-order equation never becomes the second-order equation, but the solutions become the solutions.
To get a sense of how this can happen, if we just look at this equation for phi four, we see a one over r and an r. So the formula that I just showed you that O’Brien and I derived looks very similar to a fourth-order Poisson equation. So now let’s look at it in more detail. Let me take the second-order Poisson equation. Let me solve it. Let me just integrate it. I get a one over r term here. Zero r from going to r to infinity. Take the derivative, and I get an inverse square law, zero to r, and the term out to infinity drops out. Why? That’s Newton’s theorem. For a spherical distribution of matter, the outside always drops out. And therefore, you only need to know the local matter, and if you want to do Newtonian gravity and you need dark matter, you’ve got to put the dark matter where the visible matter is.
However, now let’s do the same thing for the fourth-order theory. Solve this equation. It’s a fourth order. I’m gonna get one, two, three, four terms. Take the derivative, and I get a constant, one over r squared, and an r. So I get a linear potential, a one over r potential, and a quadratic potential. So for the fourth-order equation, I get the linear—wherever we are—the linear potential, the one over r and the quadratic. I don’t get the gamma zero c squared r, and I’m not going to be able to get that yet because it comes from relativity. So now you see that the force at a given point also is sensitive to the material out at infinity.
Curt: Now, quick question. I know you said that you haven’t implemented relativity yet, but what is the means by which the local knows about the global?
Philip: Ah, because these equations are higher derivative. It’s... See, the whole problem with Newton is that you get a one over r potential, you get a one over r squared force, and an r squared solid angle, and therefore they cancel. If I change the potential, I don’t change the solid angle, and therefore I no longer get a cancellation.
Curt: No, no, what I mean to say is what is the physical mechanism? So if something is lo... Maybe it’s a foolish question. Apologies if you’ve answered it. But as you’re wiggling, if you’re here, you look at your neighbors and they’re wiggling and so it makes you wiggle and so forth. Okay, and gravitational waves propagate gravity and so forth. Okay, so what is the physical mechanism by which the local knows about the global?
Philip: The point here is we get these linear potentials. The linear potential grows with distance. So the object which is the furthest away from you is putting out the largest potential because it’s got the largest distance. And so when a particle moves in a galaxy, it sees the local material, but it also sees the global field because the global field is not falling off like Newton. It’s a linear potential, not a one over r potential. And that is Mach’s principle. So in the end, we come back to Mach. We do have an interaction between the local and the global because the global material is having global effects on all distance scales. Whereas in Newtonian case, you can have global material, but it falls off like one over r, and so you can discuss what’s going on in the solar system without needing to know what’s going on in Andromeda. But not in this theory.
Now, this, of course, is both good news and bad news. The bad news is you can never switch off the outside, so calculations become a lot harder. The good news is the whole universe hangs together. There is no such thing as an isolated gravitational source in the universe. All gravitational sources are interacting with all other ones in a substantial manner because these potentials are not falling at large distance.
Curt: But they’re still operating at the speed of light. There’s no superluminal—
Philip: Oh, this is just non-relativistic. I haven’t made this covariant yet. You’re still... You’re always going to get retardation. Yeah, I mean, gravitational signals can still only travel at a finite velocity. I’m gonna show how that works in a few moments. And so we can see that Newtonian gravity is local, whereas the fourth-order theory is global, and therefore what’s going on outside is just as important as what’s going on inside.
Okay. So let me just show very quickly, I take a mass distribution which is non-vanishing in r less than r zero and is non-vanishing in r greater than r one, where that’s a cluster scale, and then in the region between, I can solve this equation, read off the coefficients, and then I can get all of these coefficients, and that’s the result. Finally, I take the material that’s inside the source, integrate over this surface brightness for a spiral galaxy, and I get the entire local contribution, which comes from the beta star. That’s the inside Schwarzschild term, the gamma star coming from the linear term, and then finally I add on the kappa c squared term, and that’s what I get from the fourth-order Poisson equation.
Now, I haven’t completed the story yet. I haven’t yet got this gamma zero c squared r term. But let—just—let’s just go and assume that I will get it, which I’ll show you in a moment. So now, O’Brien and I took this formula, the complete formula, not just the asymptotic one. That’s the asymptotic one. That’s the exact integrated over all the material in the galaxies, and let me just show you. Just take one simple case.
01:20:28 · Missing Mass in Plain Sight
Philip: Those are the fits. And we’re not just hitting the outs at the end. We’re hitting all the data points.
Now, what was very interesting was that when we started to do this, and I’ll show you what the issue was, initially when I first did this, I had the linear term, but I did not have—I hadn’t thought about the quadratic because the quadratic was going—
Curt: The quadratic term was too small?
Philip: The quadratic term was too small because the distances were so small. But when James O’Brien started to work with me, I previously had worked on 11 galaxies. He found 138 galaxies. I still don’t know where he found them, but he did. And what I’d said was that if you go out far enough, the linear term will take over, and the rotation curves must rise. And James diligently worked through the 138 galaxies, and these curves like this is what you would have got if I did not have the quadratic term. But the quadratic term is only one number, one coefficient, one kappa.
And so I said, “Well, the only thing we’ve got left is this one term. How many points are a problem?” And James went down the list. It turned out there were 200 data points that were still problematic. Those entire 200 data points were resolved by this one kappa term. And not only that, when we fitted the data and got the value for kappa, it came out to be a cluster of galaxy scale. We didn’t ask for it. That’s what we got from the fit. So those fits I’ve shown you really do capture all the data.
Now, having done that, the next question is, well, what happened with this RAR? So let’s see. That was—those are the fits. We fitted every data point. There’s around 4,000 data points. What happens with the RAR? We initially fit 138. Eventually, we stepped up to 207. The only variable is the N star, one number, the mass of the—and that’s the luminosity of the galaxy, which is actually measured. And we have beta star, gamma star, gamma zero. That’s not a star. Gamma zero and kappa. They’re all universal, and there’s no dark matter. Dark matter would have 276 and, later on, 414 more parameters. So we meet the Newtonian gold standard.
So my view is dark matter is just an attempt to describe global physics in local terms. It’s what’s going on outside the galaxy. Newton is local, and so you say, “I’ve got to do something inside the galaxy which will replace what’s going on outside the galaxy.” And therefore, dark matter does not exist. That’s what it is. It’s just trying to do something. It’s trying to pretend that you can redefine global physics in local terms. Where’s the missing mass? It’s the rest of the visible universe. It’s been hiding in plain sight all along. So this theory is saying there never was a missing mass problem. You just hadn’t allowed for the fact that the material outside the galaxy plays a role.
Okay. So that’s us. Now we make a prediction, and the prediction is that if you go too far out, then this number becomes negative because the—there’s a minus sign here, and that means that v squared will go negative, but v squared can never go negative because it’s a velocity, and therefore, galaxies must have a finite limiting size. And what is it? It’s N star gamma star plus gamma zero divided by two kappa. That’s—and look at these curves, and you can see that they’re all coming in around that number, and this number will never be bigger than 150 kiloparsecs as long as N star gamma star is never bigger than gamma zero. Of course, if N star gamma star is even bigger than gamma zero, then you will get the galaxy will be even bigger. But that—we’ll show you in a moment that that almost never will happen, and it’s caused by an interplay between local and global physics, which I just said a moment ago was Mach’s principle.
Now, what is the value of N star for which those two terms, the N star gamma star and the gamma zero are equal? Oh, I have to... Let me jump ahead. I’ll come back in a moment. Okay. The number for which they’re equal is when N star is five times 10^10. Now, if you plot what’s called the galaxy stellar mass function, the number of galaxies above that mass, above that 10 to the—five times 10^10 solar masses, falls very radically. There are more galaxies, but they’re very, very few. So almost all the galaxies that we know of are confined to gamma star N star is less than or equal to gamma zero. Namely, there’s a relationship between the local and the global.
So that’s why—that’s how that curve that I just wrote—that’s how this prediction, why it’s valid, is because there are very few galaxies for which N star gamma star is bigger than gamma zero.
01:26:13 · Confirmed Low-Acceleration Prediction
Philip: Okay. Now let’s go back to this curve here. I’m going to plot, instead of doing what McGaugh, Lelli—Lelli, McGaugh, and Schombert did, instead of plotting g obs against g Newton, I’m going to plot it against g local, which includes the gamma star, and you see it’s almost the same curve. Let me plot g obs against the entire conformal gravity prediction, and that is the straight line, and it almost lies on top of the straight line.
Now let’s go back to conformal gravity. So now I plot g obs against g new, the way—the Newtonian piece, the way McGaugh—Lelli, McGaugh, Lelli, and Schombert have told me to do, and I get a band. I don’t get a single line, which is what they got. I get a band, and the band straightens out. So let’s see what that means. What that means is, and I—to explore it, I broke the sample into high surface brightness, there’s the very bright galaxies, with 2,870 data points, and they’re pretty much all in this small region. Then I looked at the low surface brightness, the dwarfs and the fainter galaxies, another 2,971 points, and what I see here is it’s almost a straight line.
And the straight line is asymptoting to gamma zero c squared over two, because that’s what I have. Because in these galaxies, N star is so small that gamma zero is the only important one, the one that’s coming from the rest of the universe. And that curve falls onto 10^-10.86 meters per second per second.
Okay. Now, Lelli, McGaugh, Schombert, and Pawlowski wrote a second paper. They augmented their original set with some dwarf spheroidal data and some late-type galaxy data. And what they found was this curve here, the thick line, that’s what the radial acceleration relationship would be if they just continued it. Because now they’re going down to 10^-14, previously they were only at 10^-12, and yet their best fit is almost coming in at my number. Almost coming in at 10^-10.86.
Subsequently, there was another study by Júlio, Read, Pawlowski, Li, Vaz, Brinchmann, Rey, Agertz, and Holmes. It was only released in 2025, and these are their data. And this is the McGaugh straight line. That’s the Newton one. So the Newton one with no dark matter, with no difference at all, that’s clearly not good. The RAR of—that I showed you before of MOND and of McGaugh, Lelli, and Schombert is also no good. But these data are coalescing on 10^-11, which is exactly the conformal gravity prediction. And so I made this prediction, by the way, in 2018, and it only came in in 2025. And so I reported on this in a paper called Conformal Gravity and the Low Acceleration Limit of the Radial Acceleration Relation. Namely, my formula says that v squared over r should be going to the constant gamma zero. And that’s exactly what we see.
Now, can I do some more? Can I put all of the data points for the—for all of these—for the 207 galaxies on one plot? And so what I did was I took out the Newtonian term, and I plotted it as a function of distance. And what you see is, below around 10 kiloparsecs, I can—that can be positive or negative. But above 10 kiloparsecs, it’s positive, greater—g obs is greater than g new, and that’s a straight line. And that straight line is the gamma zero c squared over two. Those are the data. And so the data are pointing very strongly in the idea that whatever is going on at large enough distance is a universal acceleration.
Okay. So the Tully-Fisher relation, I just will state, I did the balancing, which I said before. I balance where the linear terms and the Newton terms all balance, and that gives me on this curve the—that red dotted line. And it gives me the coefficient. I don’t have to just say, “v to the fourth proportional to L,” I also say, “And I can calculate the coefficient.” And that’s what I do, and that’s that curve.
When I set that quantity equal, I get what’s called a mass-radius relation, namely the radius squared is proportional to the mass. And with v to the four proportional to the luminosity, the luminosity proportional to rho r squared, we get the fundamental plane. In other words, you draw a three-dimensional diagram involving v, L, and r, and all of the galaxies lie in a two-dimensional slice on that surface. Finally, as I mentioned before, we’re also predicting that there are very few galaxies beyond the point where these two balance.
Okay. At this point, I will say the following. I’ve gone through all the data on the rotation curves. I’ve looked for regularities in the data. Shown how conformal gravity accommodates those regularities. Of course, I had worked out the conformal theory first, so I knew what regularities to look for. But nonetheless, that’s the pattern, and the pattern is not pointing in the direction of dark matter. The pattern is saying there’s so much universality in the data, whether it’s conformal gravity or MOND or MOG, it doesn’t matter, there’s universality in the data which dark matter has to produce. And so it doesn’t say that dark matter’s wrong. I can never say that. What it does say is this is something that dark matter needs to explain.
01:33:00 · Metrics From Scratch
Philip: Okay, so that’s the first topic, the dark matter problem, and now I want to start talking about general relativity. And so the first thing I’m going to do is I’m going to talk about metrics. How do we take this theory with the fourth-order Poisson equation, how do we turn it into a covariant relativistic theory? So first thing we do is we introduce a metric. The metric enables us to generalize Pythagoras’ theorem to non-Cartesian coordinates. So Pythagoras says ds squared is dx squared plus dy squared. That’s the length of the, you know, the horizontal, the vertical, and there’s the hypotenuse. That’s Pythagoras.
So first of all, we go to relativity. So we have x one, x two, and x three spatial and the time, but now we have a minus sign between them. And if I write that out, you see why. I can write that as c squared t squared, one minus dx squared, the vector x, over dt squared, I’m sorry. And that’s c squared dt squared, one minus v squared over c squared. And so if v is equal to c, this is zero, and that’s the light cone. So you can only get the light cone in relativity if you have a relative minus sign between the time and the space. If you had dt squared plus dx squared and so on, then the only way that you could get zero would be if everything was zero. But because it’s Lorentz and not Euclidean, we can get the velocity of light to be equal to c, and then we can be on what’s called the light cone.
Now, this minus sign is a bit of a nuisance, and so there’s a way to handle it. I’ve written it as eta mu nu dx mu dx nu, where x mu and x nu are one, two, three, and t. And so I introduce an eta mu nu, which is minus one, one, one, one, and then I do the sum over all of them, and that’s what I get. And so the minus sign helps—is handled by using this metric.
Now, you immediately realize here the index is upper, which is called contravariant. Here the upper index is lower, which is called covariant. The metric is the thing that takes you between covariant and contravariant. Finally, the metric itself has an inverse, namely this is the covariant metric, and this one is the contravariant with the upper indices, and it’s just the inverse. It’s the upper one times the lower one is equal to a delta function. You can just treat these as matrices.
Now, I’ve introduced all of this notation, and it’s only a bookkeeping device to take care of the relative minus sign in ds squared. However, once you have it, then we get—we replace Newton’s law of motion for a free particle by this expression, m d two x lambda ds squared is zero, and that is the covariant version of Newton’s second law of motion. This is Newton’s second law of motion in special relativity. We haven’t done general relativity yet because it isn’t just numbers. And ds squared is called the proper time. We replace the ordinary time by the proper time.
Curt: Now, what did you mean when you said that it’s just bookkeeping? Do you mean to say that it’s not—you’re not supposed to inflate it to any other status, it’s just a mathematical trick or what?
Philip: For the moment, it’s nothing more than bookkeeping. You could, if you wanted, have replaced t by i t, worked just with the four-dimensional Pythagoras’ theorem, and at the end remembered to go back from Euclidean to Lorentz. It, as yet, it’s only bookkeeping. It’s a convenient bookkeeping device, but there’s more to it. Now—so now let’s see what this buys us. It allows us to introduce something called a geodesic.
Now, let me just make the transformation, x is r sine theta cos phi, y is r sine theta sine phi, z is r cos theta. Then the line element becomes c squared dt squared minus dr squared minus r squared d theta squared minus r squared sine squared theta d phi squared, which we’re familiar with. You write it in the same form, minus eta mu nu dx mu dx nu, and now you see that the metric, because the coordinates are now r, theta, phi, and z—r, theta, and phi, and t, we now see that there’s an r squared, there’s an r squared sine squared theta, and now the metric depends on the coordinates. So it’s no longer bookkeeping. It now depends on the coordinates. We can define the metric, and we can define its inverse, and obviously that’s just because it’s diagonal, one over r squared, one over r squared sine theta.
But now what happens to Newton’s law of motion? It’s invariant if we make linear transformations. That’s special relativity. But it’s not invariant if we transform with polar coordinates, because these equations are nonlinear.
It’s r times theta times phi. These are... And the other one is just x one plus ct. These are not linear equations.
Now, special relativity, I should just point out the following. Why do we talk about the Lorentz transformation if it was introduced by Einstein?
01:39:00 · Why Einstein Changed Newton
Philip: Einstein looked at the Maxwell equations and Newton’s laws of motion, and he realized that they had different symmetries. Now, Lorentz knew that, Poincaré knew that, and we have the Lorentz-FitzGerald contraction, which explains—tries to explain the Michelson-Morley experiment. And they recognized that there were different symmetries for Newton and for Maxwell. But they weren’t prepared to change Newton.
It was Einstein who said, “No, I’ve got to have them the same, and the way to do it is not to do something to Maxwell, but I’ve got to do something to Newton.” And that was the step that made special relativity, what—why it belongs to Einstein rather than anyone else. Because relativity deals with the issue of synchronization, and Poincaré had been working on, when the train became the main means of travel in the 19th century, how did you synchronize the time between one station in Paris and a station in Marseille? And so he was fully aware of the synchronization question. But it was Einstein that resolved it by realizing that you had to do something with Newton.
And if you remember the question that Curt asked before, why do people now go to dark matter? Because they no longer want to do something with Newton. Einstein said, “I’m going to replace Newton’s law of motion by the geodesic, and I’m going to replace Newton’s law of gravity by the Einstein equations,” which I’ll come to in a moment. But that’s it. We’re not going to change Newton again. And what I’m saying is that the data are telling you you have to do something to Newton. And that’s—and I think that’s why there’s a lot of resistance.
Anyway, so now we’ve got this metric, which now has a lot of structure to it. We introduce something called the connection, which has three indices, a very awkward object, but it’s—it depends on a derivative of the metric. And we write down an equation, which is called the geodesic equation. And this is the generalization of Newton’s law of motion. It’s absent in flat space because g is just—it—I’m sorry, it’s absent in Cartesian because g is one, and the derivative of one is zero. But in non-Cartesian, it’s there.
And this geodesic equation is general coordinate invariant. So if it’s zero in one coordinate system, it’s zero in any coordinate system. So all accelerating observers, you go in a circle, you’re accelerating, you change your direction of velocity. So all accelerating observers agree on the same equation. There’s no need for Mach. There’s no need for any interaction with the distant stars to get rid of the connection because you don’t have to get rid of the connection.
Now, more importantly, only the sum of the two with the very specific weight that I’ve shown, only the sum of the two doesn’t change under any change of coordinates. And that means that you have to have a specific relative weight between that term and that term, and that’s what enables Einstein to introduce in a moment the equivalence principle.
But now let’s just take this—let’s take this connection, take the geodesic equation, take the metric, and let me calculate for the polar coordinates the non-trivial elements in the connection. They’re just straightforward algebra. Let me go back to the geodesic equation. Let me just calculate it for the various coordinates, and I get for r, for phi, and for theta, I get second-order differential equations because the—what I—what do I have with the geodesic? A second order plus a first order. So let’s look at it again. A second order plus first order, and so on.
Now, we can look at a case we always look at, a simple case where theta is pi by two. Then these equations integrate—these equations become that one and that one, and then they integrate to conservation of angular momentum and conservation of energy with an explicit rotational energy term.
Now, anyone who goes through the usual calculation of how do we get the rotational energy is you take Newton’s law of motion and then you substitute x is r cos theta, cos phi and so on, and you have to do a lot of partial derivatives. It’s a fairly extensive calculation, but you finish up with a very... You finish up with this expression. What I’m showing you is using the trick of covariance, it’s much easier to do. It falls out automatically, and then when I... If I were to give you a transformation that would be altogether more complicated, you just use this equation. So it holds in every case, but there are very few cases where you can do it analytically using... By actually transforming the coordinates themselves. What this is saying is, get the metric, get the geodesic, and then you’ve got the equations of motion.
Okay.
01:44:31 · Riemann Tensor: Real Gravity
Philip: Now, we have a puzzle. So I’ve introduced a metric over here. Now, the puzzle is, suppose I just give you some arbitrary metric. How do we know whether we can get back to an inertial frame? How do we know whether we can get back to Cartesian? Well, we can go back from polar to Cartesian because we know that, but what happens in general? And the general answer was given by Riemann.
To be a general coordinate vector, just as x mu is a special relativistic rank-one tensor, fancy words, a general coordinate vector transforms as v prime is dx prime, dx, v of x when x goes to x prime. Any quantity that behaves like that is called a vector or a rank-one tensor, because there’s only one index. The geodesic equation, that function, is a rank-one tensor, and if it’s zero in one frame, it’s zero in every frame.
Riemann found the following quantity. It involves derivatives of the connection and products of the connection, and he showed that this was a rank-four tensor. Namely, it had four indices. You go to the prime system, x prime, x prime, x prime, x prime, x, x, x, x is the Riemann tensor in the original system. It does transform that way, and so it’s a tensor. If it is zero, it is zero in every frame, and if it’s zero in every frame, you can get back to Cartesian. And if it’s non-zero, even if one component is non-zero, you can never get back to Cartesian. A simple example you can work through is take the—just put here a factor two. Put x is 2r sin theta cos phi, but leave the others the same, and you’ll find that you can never get back to Cartesian.
So that’s the end of the geometry. Now, where does Einstein come in? Einstein realized that when the Riemann tensor is non-zero, we have curvature, and therefore we have gravity. So Einstein starts with special relativity, where it looks like it’s just bookkeeping, and he converts this one, one, minus one into a metric with a non-zero Riemann tensor, and he converts one into gravity. That’s, to me, that’s utterly amazing. I find it absolutely staggering. I’ve been teaching and working in this field for many years. I still am staggered that he was able to do that. But that’s how it works.
So now we have... Now we’ve got the metric and we’ve got the connection, but what’s it got to do with gravity? We’ve agreed that if the Riemann tensor is non-zero, there is gravity, but how much? How do we get to Newton’s law of gravity? So we take the metric, and we let it be such that g zero, zero is almost equal to minus one, just a little bit off, very, very small. Calculate the geodesic. Here, the only one that matters is that one. Plug it into... Calculate the connection. Plug it into the geodesic, and you get this equation, where you’ve identified h zero is minus two phi over c squared.
So what you finish up with is if you take the metric to have a small piece, which you can say, since this is the coefficient of dt squared, we’re metricating time. And if you do that, and you write it as minus two phi over c squared, then you come up with Newton’s law of motion in a potential, just from the geometry. Finally, if you take the potential to be the one over r potential, then that equation becomes Newton’s law of gravity. So we see from this calculation why we should represent the metric with the gravitational potential as the metric, which it didn’t have to be.
Finally, if you take that form for g zero, zero, you’ll find that the Riemann tensor is non-zero, spacetime is curved, and gravity is real. And so the big deal about this expression is that it allows you to discover when you have real gravity and when you have the fake gravity that we saw right at the beginning, where Mach just said x prime was x plus a half gt squared. And that was a fake, but this one’s not a fake because this one leaves the Riemann tensor non-zero. And we’re no longer in a flat space. And so that’s the first step.
01:49:50 · Equivalence Principle Derived
Philip: From the geodesic, we immediately get the equivalence principle in the relationship that the inertial mass and the gravitational mass are equal, because it’s m times this term plus the same m times that term. This term is the inertial, Newton’s law of motion, and that’s the gravity, the connection, and the two m’s are equal, which is the equivalence principle. And so we now establish, and this is what drove—one of the things that drove Einstein along, was he’s now established why the Eötvös experiment was able to show that these numbers were so close.
Okay. Now, we get something else. The connection is not a coordinate tensor. It can’t be because only the sum of these two doesn’t change under the transformation. And, I mean, if you think of the following, you take x squared plus y squared as a constant, you rotate x and you rotate y, but x squared plus y squared is still a constant, you’re just at a different point on the circle. And this is all this is doing, only it’s doing it in a curved space. But basically, it’s the same idea.
Okay. So, however, it’s not a coordinate tensor, but it’s only the first derivative of the metric. And so if we calculate the value of the connection at a particular point and make this coordinate transformation, we will discover that the next—the transformed connection is zero. Namely, we are able to remove the connection at any given point. If the space is flat, then of course we can do it everywhere. But if the space is not flat, we can see that a gravitational field is equivalent to an acceleration, which is the other way of saying the equivalence principle.
But when... So now we have another puzzle. Why do we then have real gravity if we can remove this? The answer is, you can’t at the same time get rid of the connection at an adjacent point. And the reason is, the value of the connection at one point and the value at an adjacent point, the difference between them is the derivative of the connection, and the derivative of the connection is related to the Riemann tensor. And so what happens is that when we do this, if the Riemann tensor is non-zero, we can never remove the gravitational field. We can remove it at a point, but we can’t remove it everywhere. And then gravity is real.
Okay. So now, we—where do we stand? When the Riemann tensor is zero, we’ve written Newton’s second law of motion in an accelerating coordinate system. When the Riemann tensor is non-zero, we’ve written Newton’s law of gravity in an accelerating coordinate system, inasmuch as the geodesic equation tells a particle how to respond to an external field. All of this is generic and should hold in any general relativistic theory of gravity. Thus, gravity is a metric theory. Spacetime curvature due to non-vanishing Riemann tensor is gravity. The metric describes the gravitational field. It couples in a general coordinate way and obeys the equivalence principle. All of those features, I don’t see any way that they cannot hold.
However, there’s something that is not included yet, and that is we haven’t yet determined what the metric is. We’ve determined how a particle responds to a metric by seeing the—by moving on the geodesic, but we haven’t determined the metric. Now, at the time Einstein was doing this, the metric was given by the second-order Poisson equation with the solution which is the one over r. And Einstein asked the question, “What does the second-order Poisson equation look like in an accelerating coordinate system?” So we have to try to find a way to generalize this and to give it a coordinate invariant meaning.
And now we notice something. This is a second-order equation, and the Riemann tensor is also a second derivative because the metric’s the first derivative of the potential. And so Einstein proposed it has to be related to the Riemann tensor. But the metric’s only got 10 components, and the Riemann tensor, because it’s got four indices, has got 20 components, and that’s too many.
01:55:00 · Building Einstein's Equations
Philip: So he looked at what’s called the Ricci tensor, which is the trace of the Riemann tensor. You sum over two indices, so you’ve only got two indices left, and you take the trace of the Ricci tensor, which is called the Ricci scalar, which has no indices.
And Einstein introduced a particular thing called the Einstein tensor, which is the Ricci tensor minus a half g mu nu times the Ricci scalar. And the point here is this quantity has 10 components because R mu nu had 10, g mu nu has 10, and therefore an equation for the Einstein tensor is an equation which is a second-order derivative equation of the metric, and then you can solve for the metric.
Why did he take this particular quantity? Because when you take derivatives, remember for the connection, we already ran into this problem. When we take a derivative, we get—we have an effect which depends on the geometry. So if you take the Einstein tensor, and you want to take its derivative, you have to introduce something else which depends on the geometry, which is also called a connection, and that is also called the covariant derivative. The metric has this form. That’s the covariant derivative because the derivative involves the nearby geometry, and the nearby geometry is categorized by the connection. The metric itself is covariantly conserved all on its own. The energy-momentum tensor is covariantly conserved, and then we finish up with the Einstein equations.
So the Einstein equations were motivated by having a second-order theory because Poisson’s equation was second order, based on the Ricci tensor because there’s only 10 components of the metric, has to be related to T mu nu, and this expression reduces to this one when the geometry is almost flat, namely the moment I’d added before. When g zero zero is very close to h zero zero to one with just this little h zero zero, this equation reduces to the second-order Poisson equation.
Curt: Professor, I do have to say, that’s a master class on its own, the past 50 minutes explaining general relativity pretty much from scratch.
Philip: Yeah. Well, thank you. Your remark is very kind. You don’t realize how many years this took.
Okay. So what about the source? Well, the source, we usually take it to have a pressure and a density. That’s called a perfect fluid. Now, if we look at the Einstein equation, in the region where the source is zero, then R mu nu is equal to minus a half g mu nu R. Take the trace. The trace of R mu nu is R itself. The trace of g mu nu is four, so that becomes R minus two R is zero, and therefore, the Ricci scalar is zero. But if the Ricci scalar is zero and T mu nu is zero, then in empty space, the Ricci tensor is zero, and that’s called Ricci-flat.
Einstein only worked, as I showed you a moment ago, but Schwarzschild came along, and he solved that equation exactly, and this is the Schwarzschild metric. And it has this one over r form, which is what we want. It has correction terms because you expand this out, and you get v squared over c squared corrections. And if it holds all the way down to r equals zero, then... Oh, sorry, if it holds down to r is two mG over c squared, then that becomes zero, and this becomes infinite, and that’s the so-called Schwarzschild radius of a star, and that’s the black hole condition.
Now, you can evaluate this Ricci-flat quantity out, and you’ll find that the Riemann tensor, when you evaluate it out, is equal to that quantity, and therefore you know you are not in a flat space. We know we have gravity. Now let’s go back to Newton’s law a moment ago. We had v squared over r is mG over r squared, and therefore v squared over c squared is mG over c squared r. And that’s a v squared over c squared correction. And I said before, we can write the metric as one minus v squared over c squared, and therefore the correction to Newton is a Newton term times this mG over c squared r, so the product of these two, which is m squared G squared over c squared r cubed. When you calculate that number, I just put the numbers in, it’s of order 10^-8.
In other words, Einstein not only gets Newton’s law of—Newton—the Poisson law in an accelerating coordinate system, he gets the v squared over c squared correction. The v squared over c squared correction gives a term of one over r cubed. No precession, we saw at the beginning, only requires one over r, and therefore there must be precession. You put the numbers in, the v squared over c squared calculation, and the v was 48 kilometers per second, I showed you when we drew the Kepler curve before. Divide by c squared. That number is 10^-8, and so there’s a one part in 10^8 modification to the orbit of Mercury. So that was the—what he discovered.
02:00:54 · Light Bending and Ricci Flatness
Philip: He then makes a prediction that in this geometry, gravity will travel and bend by the Sun, and there’ll be a gravitational redshift. And when you calculate them out, and the experiments came in at just the right amount, why is it doing this? Because spacetime is acting like a refractive medium. In other words, photons are not traveling through empty space anymore. It’s like they’re traveling through a refractive index glass, which distorts the motion. Light goes through a glass, and it gets bent, and therefore you will get a bending of the same kind from gravity. And when the gravitational redshift came in in 1921—by the way, the redshift didn’t come in until 1960, but already by 1921, the general consensus of the community was that gravity had been solved.
However, what has happened is all you’ve done is you’ve checked that the geometry outside the Sun is Ricci-flat. And therefore, there is a possibility that you can have a different theory that would still give Ricci-flat outside the Sun.
Curt: Now, that’s a subtle point because most of the time you think that... Well, most people think you’ve tested Einstein’s theory, but you’ve tested the solutions to Einstein’s theory, and we talked about that on the podcast before. Please go into a minor amount of detail on that just right now for those who haven’t seen the first one. And I do wanna say, for the audience, I’ve watched many, many, many lectures, many lectures, read many books. You have no idea how compendious the past 60 minutes are on general relativity alone. So not only is this a lecture on dark matter and quantum gravity, we haven’t even got to that part yet, on gravity itself, it’s self-contained.
Philip: All right. Thank you. Okay, the statement is the following. I’ve got the Ricci tensor vanishes. I solve for the Einstein equations with Ricci tensor vanishing, and I come up with the Schwarzschild solution. From the Schwarzschild solution, I go back and I calculate, as we did before. I’ve now got the metric. I calculate the connection, and I calculate the geodesic. And so when I do that, what I find is, in principle, when I do that, I’ve got the motion of a particle in this geometry, namely in a Ricci-flat geometry, and I can make this number as big or small as I want. And that is what people do when they try to calculate how does a particle move in the vicinity of a black hole.
But for weak gravity, where two mG over c squared r is very much less than one, we only... We get back. You can see immediately, here’s the Newton term. Here is a dr squared over dt squared is a v squared over c squared correction. Calculate out what v squared over c squared is, knowing that v squared over r is mG over r squared. And then you get the correction is m squared G squared over c squared r cubed. That’s the v squared over c squared correction to Newton’s law of gravity.
You put the numbers in. We know the velocity of Mercury is 48 kilometers per second. The velocity of light is 3 times 10^5 kilometers per second. The ratio is of order 10^-8. And so going all the way back, let’s go all the way back to this Kepler curve. Okay, here’s the Kepler curve. That is only on the curve with no precession. It comes back to itself. Any departure from one over r will move it slightly off the Newtonian curve. What Einstein managed to do was to find a correction, and since it goes like a one over r cubed, it won’t give a precession, therefore it will move us off the Kepler curve, but it moves us off by exactly the amount, the amount that’s measured. And that, of course, was absolutely startling.
Now, by the way, when Einstein first calculated the gravitational bending of light, he used the equivalence principle, which is effectively using this term, and he was off by a factor of two. And because all he has here is time dilation. But over here, the dr squared over dt squared is v squared over c squared, but v is c. So that’s a term of order one, and that is Lorentz contraction of the length. That gives a second factor, and then he gets the right gravitational bending. So half of it comes from time dilation, and half of it comes from Lorentz contraction, and that’s the right number.
Okay. Now, what’s going on? The deep thing is not Newton’s law of gravity or its corrections. The deep thing is that light is affected by gravity. Now, light is bent from a straight line, and a straight line is the flat space geodesic, and it’s bent into a curved space geodesic. But light has no mass, and therefore, if we just stayed with Newton, light should not interact with the gravitational field. And so this is the very deep thing.
The second deep thing, according to Einstein, and we’ll come back to that in a moment, there is nothing that does not couple to gravity. Wherever you write a derivative, you have to replace it by a covariant derivative, which means you’re sensitive to the geometry. And if you have general coordinate invariance, then everything couples to gravity. Now, I’m emphasizing this now because shortly we’ll see that this is where the... This, it—ignoring this gives you the cosmological constant problem. But for the moment, we’ll just make the statement. And what is not... And that’s just geometry. That’s nothing to do with the Einstein equations.
Einstein says that light couples to geometry independent of how big or what field the metric obeys. Now—
02:07:45 · Are Einstein's Equations Unique?
Philip: However, despite all of its solar system successes, the Einstein equations were constructed based on the a priori validity of Newton’s law of gravity, because he just generalizes it. Therefore, if you take the Einstein equations, you are committed to its validity for non-relativistic motion on all scales, and thus you are forced to dark matter. So, if the Einstein equations, which everybody thinks are the correct equations of gravity, when you apply them to galaxies or even bigger systems, you are forced to dark matter. Therefore, the only way you have a hope to get rid of the need for dark matter is you have to keep all of this, as we said before, but you have the freedom to change the equation which fixes the geometry as long as it’s general coordinate invariant.
Okay. Now, what can we say about these equations? To get the Einstein equations, you take an action which consists of the Ricci scalar, you do a variation which means you find the shortest distance between two endpoints in the presence of the Ricci scalar, and that is the Einstein equation. And outside the source, as I said a moment ago, you get a Ricci-flat geometry.
Now, as early as 1922, Eddington raised an objection. He says if the action is based on a higher power of the Ricci scalar or the Ricci tensor, Ricci-flat is still a vacuum solution. In much the same way, we saw that one over r goes with del squared or del four, Ricci-flat goes with Ricci scalar or square of Ricci scalar. Those theories are called quadratic gravity, and we’ll get back to them shortly. So, Ricci-flat is not unique to Einstein.
So, Eddington’s result was, as early as 1922, Einstein did this in 1915, the Einstein equations are sufficient to give the Schwarzschild solution, namely Ricci-flat, but not necessary. Assuming them to be necessary causes the dark matter problem. Now, beyond that, Einstein himself considered a modification of his own equations as he added onto the action a cosmological constant term. It would act repulsively and counterbalance standard gravitational attraction and lead to a static universe, something that Einstein had taken to be the case. Einstein dropped lambda when Hubble showed the universe was not static but was expanding, and it’s now come back into vogue as dark energy, causing the universe not only to expand but to even accelerate.
Now, the key point here is not whether higher derivatives of the Ricci scalar or a cosmological constant term are relevant, but the fact that one could consider adding them in at all indicates that the Einstein-Hilbert action is not unique. Now, we’d showed earlier that the second-order Poisson equation is not necessary but only sufficient to yield Newton’s law of gravity, with a fourth-order one also leading to Newton’s laws of gravity. So now we need a principle which will tell us should we use the second, should we use the fourth.
And in doing that, we need to generalize not Poisson, but we need to generalize Schwarzschild. Because we’ve already established that the Schwarzschild metric works in the solar system. So I think it’s too late in the history of physics to not think in terms of generalizing Schwarzschild, even though I had worked through with Poisson at the beginning. So how do we generalize Schwarzschild? We need a principle to uniquely fix the gravity theory. The principle I’ll use is conformal invariance, and it leads to a fourth-order equation and eliminates the need for dark matter.
Curt: If you want access to the next conversation prior to anyone else, plus my actual opinions on these theories and concepts, which I keep out of the interviews, then visit my Substack, curtjaimungal.com. That’s C-U-R-T-J-A-I-M-U-N-G-A-L.com. And if today’s conversation grabbed you, there’s an episode on screen somewhere right now over here, which is the next one that I’d watch. Enjoy.
Thank you for reading. So, what do you think about the ideas in this post? Leave a comment / share if you like.
—Curt Jaimungal
PS: Consider becoming a paying member on this Substack. This is how I earn a living, as I’m directly reader-supported. Moreover, you’ll get a slew of exclusive content such as early access to full podcasts. If you like the free content, you’ll love the members-only content.
Links Mentioned
Prior TOE Episodes
Papers
Shown on screen, by other authors
Modified Gravity (MOG), Cosmology and Black Holes. J. W. Moffat.
MOND theory. Mordehai Milgrom.
The radial acceleration relation at the EDGE of galaxy formation: testing its universality in low-mass dwarf galaxies. M. P. Júlio, J. I. Read, M. S. Pawlowski and others. Astronomy and Astrophysics 704, A330 (2025).
Mannheim's bibliography, part one: conformal gravity, the cosmological constant, and dark matter
Conformal cosmology with no cosmological constant. P. D. Mannheim. General Relativity and Gravitation 22, 289 (1990).
Exact vacuum solution to conformal Weyl gravity and galactic rotation curves. P. D. Mannheim and D. Kazanas. Astrophysical Journal 342, 635 (1989).
General structure of the gravitational equations of motion in conformal Weyl gravity. D. Kazanas and P. D. Mannheim. Astrophysical Journal Supplement Series 76, 431 (1991).
Solutions to the Reissner-Nordstrom, Kerr and Kerr-Newman problems in fourth order conformal Weyl gravity. P. D. Mannheim and D. Kazanas. Physical Review D 44, 417 (1991).
Conformal gravity and the flatness problem. P. D. Mannheim. Astrophysical Journal 391, 429 (1992).
Dynamical mass and geodesic motion. P. D. Mannheim. General Relativity and Gravitation 25, 697 (1993).
Linear potentials and galactic rotation curves. P. D. Mannheim. Astrophysical Journal 419, 150 (1993).
Newtonian limit of conformal gravity and the lack of necessity of the second order Poisson equation. P. D. Mannheim and D. Kazanas. General Relativity and Gravitation 26, 337 (1994).
Open questions in classical gravity. P. D. Mannheim. Foundations of Physics 24, 487 (1994).
Linear potentials in galaxies and clusters of galaxies. P. D. Mannheim. April 1995.
Cosmology and galactic rotation curves. P. D. Mannheim. November 1995.
Conformal cosmology and the age of the universe. P. D. Mannheim. January 1996.
Linear potentials and galactic rotation curves - detailed fitting. P. D. Mannheim and J. Kmetko. February 1996.
Are galactic rotation curves really flat?. P. D. Mannheim. Astrophysical Journal 479, 659 (1997).
Local and global gravity. P. D. Mannheim. Foundations of Physics 26, 1683 (1996).
Curvature and cosmic repulsion. P. D. Mannheim. March 1998.
Implications of cosmic repulsion for gravitational theory. P. D. Mannheim. Physical Review D 58, 103511 (1998).
Cosmic acceleration as the solution to the cosmological constant problem. P. D. Mannheim. Astrophysical Journal 561, 1 (2001).
Attractive and repulsive gravity. P. D. Mannheim. Foundations of Physics 30, 709 (2000).
How recent is cosmic acceleration?. P. D. Mannheim. International Journal of Modern Physics D 12, 893 (2003).
Alternatives to dark matter and dark energy. P. D. Mannheim. Progress in Particle and Nuclear Physics 56, 340 (2006).
Schwarzschild limit of conformal gravity in the presence of macroscopic scalar fields. P. D. Mannheim. Physical Review D 75, 124006 (2007).
Comprehensive Solution to the cosmological constant, zero-point energy, and quantum gravity problems. P. D. Mannheim. General Relativity and Gravitation 43, 703 (2011).
Intrinsically quantum-mechanical gravity and the cosmological constant problem. P. D. Mannheim. Modern Physics Letters A 26, 2375 (2011).
Impact of a global quadratic potential on galactic rotation curves. P. D. Mannheim and J. G. O’Brien. Physical Review Letters 106, 121101(2011).
Fitting galactic rotation curves with conformal gravity and a global quadratic potential. P. D. Mannheim and J. G. O’Brien. Physical Review D 85, 124020 (2012).
Making the case for conformal gravity. P. D. Mannheim. Foundations of Physics 42, 388 (2012).
Fitting dwarf galaxy rotation curves with conformal gravity. J. G. O’Brien and P. D. Mannheim. Monthly Notices of the Royal Astronomical Society 421, 1273 (2012).
Cosmological perturbations in conformal gravity. P. D. Mannheim. Physical Review D 85, 124008 (2012).
Galactic rotation curves in conformal gravity. P. D. Mannheim and J. G. O’Brien. Journal of Physics: Conference Series 437, 012002 (2013).
Living without supersymmetry – the conformal alternative and a dynamical Higgs boson. P. D. Mannheim. Journal of Physics G 44, 115003 (2017)..
Comment on "Problems with Mannheim's conformal gravity program". P. D. Mannheim. Physical Review D 93, 068501 (2016).
Mass generation, the cosmological constant problem, conformal symmetry, and the Higgs boson. P. D. Mannheim. Progress in Particle and Nuclear Physics 94, 125 (2017).
Is the cosmological constant problem properly posed?. P. D. Mannheim. International Journal of Modern Physics D 26, 1743009 (2017)..
Universal properties of galactic rotation curves and a first principles derivation of the Tully-Fisher relation. J. G. O’Brien, T. L. Chiarelli and P. D. Mannheim. Physics Letters B 782, 433 (2018).
Cosmological perturbations in conformal gravity. II. A. Amarasinghe, M. G. Phelps and P. D. Mannheim. Physical Review D 99, 083527 (2019).
Radial Acceleration and Tully-Fisher Relations in Conformal Gravity. J. G. O’Brien, T. L. Chiarelli, P. D. Mannheim, M. A. Falcone, M. H. AlQurashi and J. Carter. Journal of Physics: Conference Series (in press).
Is dark matter fact or fantasy? – clues from the data. P. D. Mannheim. International Journal of Modern Physics D 28, 1944022 (2019).
Three-dimensional and four-dimensional scalar, vector, tensor cosmological fluctuations and the cosmological decomposition theorem. M. Phelps, A. Amarasinghe and P. D. Mannheim. General Relativity and Gravitation 52, 114 (2020).
Exact solution to perturbative conformal cosmology in the recombination era. P. D. Mannheim. Physical Review D 102, 123535 (2020).
Cosmological Fluctuations on the Light Cone. A. Amarasinghe and P. D. Mannheim. Physical Review D 103, 103517 (2021).
Exact solution to perturbative conformal cosmology from recombination until the current era. A. Amarasinghe, T. Liu, D. A. Norman and P. D. Mannheim. Physical Review D 103, 104022 (2021).
External field effect in gravity. P. D. Mannheim and J. W. Moffat. International Journal of Modern Physics D 30, 2142009 (2021).
Critique of the use of geodesics in astrophysics and cosmology. P. D. Mannheim. Classical and Quantum Gravity 39, 245001 (2022).
Structure of conformal gravity in the presence of a scale breaking scalar field. P. D. Mannheim. General Relativity and Gravitation 54, 99 (2022).
How to quantize gravity and how not to quantize gravity. P. D. Mannheim. European Physics Journal Plus 138, 262 (2023).
Imprint of galactic rotation curves and metric fluctuations on the recombination era anisotropy. P. D. Mannheim. Physics Letters B 840, 137851 (2023).
Properties of associated Legendre conical functions. D. A. Norman, P. D. Mannheim and T. Liu.
Creating a Universe from Nothing as an Alternative to the Cosmological Principle. P. D. Mannheim, D. A. Norman and T. Liu. Physical Review D 113, 063572 (2026).
Conformal gravity and the low acceleration limit of the radial acceleration relation. P. D. Mannheim. November 6 2025.
Mannheim's bibliography, part two: ghost problems, unitarity of fourth-order theories, and PT quantum mechanics
Fourth order theories without ghosts. P. D. Mannheim and A. Davidson. January 2000.
Dirac quantization of the Pais-Uhlenbeck fourth order oscillator. P. D. Mannheim and A. Davidson. Physical Review A 71, 042110 (2005).
Solution to the ghost problem in fourth order derivative theories. P. D. Mannheim. Foundations of Physics 37, 532 (2007).
No-ghost theorem for the fourth-order derivative Pais-Uhlenbeck oscillator model. C. M. Bender and P. D. Mannheim. Physical Review Letters 100, 110402 (2008).
Giving up the ghost. C. M. Bender and P. D. Mannheim. Journal of Physics A 41, 304018 (2008).
Exactly solvable PT-symmetric Hamiltonian having no Hermitian counterpart. C. M. Bender and P. D. Mannheim. Physical Review D 78, 025022 (2008).
PT symmetry and necessary and sufficient conditions for the reality of energy eigenvalues. C. M. Bender and P. D. Mannheim. Physics Letters A 374, 1616 (2010).
PT symmetry as a necessary and sufficient condition for unitary time evolution. P. D. Mannheim. Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society A 371, 20120060 (2013).
PT symmetry in relativistic quantum mechanics. C. M. Bender and P. D. Mannheim. Physical Review D 84, 105038 (2011).
Astrophysical evidence for the non-Hermitian but PT-symmetric Hamiltonian of conformal gravity. P. D. Mannheim. Fortschritte der Physik 61, 140 (2013).
PT symmetry, conformal symmetry, and the metrication of electromagnetism. P. D. Mannheim. Foundations of Physics 47, 1229 (2017).
Advancing the case for PT symmetry – the Hamiltonian is always PT symmetric. P. D. Mannheim.
Extension of the CPT Theorem to non-Hermitian Hamiltonians and unstable states. P. D. Mannheim. Physics Letters B 753, 288 (2016).
Antilinearity rather than Hermiticity as a guiding principle for quantum theory. P. D. Mannheim. Journal of Physics A 51, 315302 (2018).
Appropriate inner product for PT-Symmetric Hamiltonians. P. D. Mannheim. Physical Review D 97, 045001 (2018).
Unitarity of loop diagrams for the ghostlike 1/(k²−M₁²) − 1/(k²−M₂²) propagator. P. D. Mannheim. Physical Review D 98, 045014 (2018).
Goldstone bosons and the Higgs mechanism in non-Hermitian theories. P. D. Mannheim. Physical Review D 99, 045006 (2019).
Ghost problems from Pauli-Villars to fourth-order quantum gravity and their resolution. P. D. Mannheim. International Journal of Modern Physics D 29, 2043009 (2020).
Antilinear symmetry and the ghost problem in quantum field theory. P. D. Mannheim. Proceedings of Virtual Seminar Series on Pseudo-Hermitian Hamiltonians in Quantum Physics, IOP Conference Series 2038, 012018 (2021).
Extension of the Goldstone and the Englert-Brout-Higgs mechanisms to non-Hermitian theories. P. D. Mannheim. Journal of Physics Conference Series (in press).
Exceptional points for associated Legendre functions of the second kind. T. Liu, D. A. Norman and P. D. Mannheim. Journal of Mathematical Physics 65, 033505 (2024).
Determining the normalization of the quantum field theory vacuum, with implications for quantum gravity. P. D. Mannheim. Classical and Quantum Gravity 40, 205007 (2023).
Normalization of the vacuum and the ultraviolet completion of Einstein gravity. P. D. Mannheim. International Journal of Modern Physics D 32, 2350096 (2023).
Time advance and probability conservation in PT-symmetric quantum mechanics. P. D. Mannheim. Physical Review D Letters 112, L031903 (2025).
PT symmetry and the square well potential: Antilinear symmetry rather than Hermiticity in scattering processes. P. D. Mannheim.
States that grow linearly in time, exceptional points, and zero norm states in the simple harmonic oscillator. P. D. Mannheim.
Critique of Breit-Wigner resonance scattering. P. D. Mannheim. May 27 2026.
Other References
Shown on Screen in Part 1
Hubble image of the Pinwheel Galaxy M101 (NASA, ESA; CC BY 4.0) (Image)
MIT Scientist's Discovery: "Black Holes Might Be Dark Matter!" | David Kaiser (TOE)
Nothing But Ratios: The Universe Barbour Discovered | Julian Barbour (TOE)
Dark matter experiments get a first peek at the neutrino fog (Science News) (article)
The "Inverse Problem" Of Dark Matter Is Insane | Jenny Wagner (TOE)
Lost in Math? Questioning Physics Dogmas | Sabine Hossenfelder (TOE)
This Physicist (Unexpectedly) Derived Gravity from Information | Erik Verlinde (TOE)












