Laden with the sadness of Mortal Man Doomed to Die, we all too soon join the masses of the Dead, the brief candle of consciousness snuffed out. It's absurd! So of course we must believe in some form of soul and some form of immortality, else we live out our lives in the dark shadow of Grief and Death. Science and Reason can give us no comfort, so, like children, we must seek comfort;
Every major faith tradition independently arrived at the same answer to the deepest question: before the universe, there was nothing — and from that nothing, by an act of intelligence, everything emerged.
Physics spent the last century arriving at the same place from the opposite direction. Feynman, Hawking, Guth, Krauss — independent calculations, different decades, one result: the total energy of the universe is zero. Matter plus gravity equals nothing. The universe, taken as a whole, has the same value as the nothing that preceded it.
The experience of the divine and the equations of physics are not in conflict. They are converging on the same boundary — the one place physics reaches and stops: the uncaused first cause.
The Indeterminate Null framework is the first proposed mechanism that begins from absolute zero — no prior fields, no prior laws, no prior anything — and derives time, space, and matter through a single logical constraint. It makes the gap explicit. And it acknowledges honestly what lives in that gap.
Whether you call it God, the Tao, Brahman, or the null state — the physics agrees something was there.
Something from Nothing Pt. 5 — God and Physics Agree: The Universe from Nothing [link to video]
One of the notable aspects of discussions of “god” amongst positivist thinkers like Curt and his guest, Tanya Luhrmann, is that they never attempt to define what god is. If they were discussing, say, ethics, Aristotle, string theory, and so on, they would attempt at some stage, usually at the beginning, to define or at least describe the thing they were discussing. But god is different. The concept of god is taken as given and so everyone knows what they are talking about. This is very, very significant for what it tells us about atheism. The nearest this discussion comes to describing god is to say he is like a kiddy’s teddy bear. This is pop psychologism at its worse and should have no place in a serious discussion.
Even madcap atheists, like Harris and Dawkins, never say what god is but simply refute his existence without saying what they are refuting. But they must know somewhere in their minds what god is, and assume their audience has a similar understanding, to so emphatically claim to refute his existence. In this they are ahead of Christians, like me, who would never assume to understand god as well as these godless propagandists apparently do.
I will return to the understanding of god in a moment but let’s first look briefly at this discussion between Curt and Tanya Luhrmann. The title of the discussion is “The Experience Is Real. But Is God [real]?.” Luhrmann argues that people must work incredibly hard to make gods real. So the unstated assumption is that god is not real. She says “is real” and “feels real” are two different phenomena. “Is real” is that you have the propositional commitment. I believe that this tree is in front of me, I believe in God. “Feels real” is something more experiential.
The blurb to her book, How God Becomes Real, states “How do gods and spirits come to feel vividly real to people—as if they were standing right next to them? Humans tend to see supernatural agents everywhere, as the cognitive science of religion has shown. But it isn’t easy to maintain a sense that there are invisible spirits who care about you. In How God Becomes Real, acclaimed anthropologist and scholar of religion T. M. Luhrmann argues that people must work incredibly hard to make gods real.”
She is a psychologist as well as an anthropologist and here her anthropological researches lead her to the psychologist approach. What is psychologism? It is the use of psychology to explain behaviour and belief. This means a positivism explanation. In this, the individual is reduced for they are just performing according laid down models. Psychologism is usually attributed to J.S.Mill, the early nineteenth century philosophy. There was a strong reaction to this view in the early twentieth century but in today’s highly positivist intellectual landscape it has a natural fit.
There is a lot of talk of spirituality in this discussion with statistics telling us that a lot of people consider themselves to be spiritual but not religious. This is the closest we get to breeching the psychologist/positivist barrier with the associated admission that there is something beyond the material world.
But spiritual is never defined. It is merely linked to New Age and the “shift away from traditional faiths, and tolerance of other ways of thinking about the faith”, for instance, the Beatles taking up Maharishi yogi in the 1960s. There was a mishmash of ideas that emerged that came to be called the New Age. But this does not confront god. (It is a bit like Sam Harris claiming he already has been down the religion route with meditation, although it is amazing that someone who does meditation every day could remain impervious to anything beyond the material.)
The discussion here is entitled The Experience Is Real. But Is God [Real]? The second part is not really dealt with but the assumption is in the negative because “people must work incredibly hard to make gods real”. So they are a fabrication. However, the experience of god can be real just as the experience of anything real or imaginary can be real. I don’t think that is saying anything.
I would file Luhrmann’s ideas under Present Attacks on Religion. By saying it is constructed by humans she rejects religion. Once you are locked into positivism there is really no other way to go. The only way to look at it differently is through phenomenology which is diametrically opposed to positivism.
Phenomenology constructs quite a different reality where the viewer and world are not separated as positivism demands. In this you do not set up the question of god’s existence as a scientific matter to be cracked. That is considered meaningless – especially as we have seen positivists never attempt to define god. To put it briefly god is “given”, or in Martin Heidegger’s term “disclosed” (although he does not use this term in this context). God just is.
That positivists never attempt to define god affirms, unwittingly, the phenomenological view, for the lack of definition establishes firmly that god is given/disclosed without need for context or reference. The psychologism of Luhrmann is pretty much of a red herring. She writes detailed accounts of how humans in different cultures “construct” god but if god is given without compromise that it is not god that is being constructed. She is observing different cultures weaving different tapestries around an idea that is natural and undeniable to all humans
Curt, you say you read all the comments. Please comment here to confirm you have read this. And how about some feedback? Is this a discussion or what?
Positivism is the appropriate method in science and mathematics which is what you mostly do. But it cannot apply to philosophy as philosophy can never produce scientific truth. If it could it would be science not philosophy. Positivist philosophy which appears to be the mainstream today seeks to apply the scientific positivist method to philosophy. This is disastrous and ultimately nihilistic. It is an impossible project producing endless discussion and papers to justify academic careers. I see you are unhappy with positivist but you try to climb out of the positivist box into mysticism and new ageism. These are the other side of the coin of positivism and not the way to go. Still, keep questioning. You may find your way. In my view that will not happen until you embrace phenomenology and life philosophy. Of course you have to start by understanding what those thing are. They are not really difficult except that our culture trains us in positivism as being the only way so getting there needs to be a leap of thought
I wrote that “you try to climb out of the positivist box into mysticism and new ageism.”.
To take mysticism first in This Is A Strange Post , Jul 07, 2026, you wrote
"Where I Side With the Mystics.
A theory of everything in the formal sense may turn out to be smaller than an account of Everything there is.
William James said there are some experiences that “defy expression.” Such states “must be directly experienced; it cannot be imparted or transferred to others.” It can’t be imparted whole, from within.
James heard that as words failing the mystic but it might just be the mystic being early. Why? Well, the fantasy that fails is the vantage point outside your own experience, and the mystics seem to have caught something quite before the logicians did. In fact, this happens more than you think. Washing hands tends to lead to stronger confessions.
As someone who petitions for precision by professional position, I also keep a place for mystery. James did as well. He said that if you lack the ear, you would rate the musician as “weak-minded or absurd,” and “the mystic finds that most of us accord to his experiences an equally incompetent treatment.”
I posted in my comment.
"But you do not need mysticism. That is always a cop out – an acknowledgement that you do not have the answer. And mysticism is NOT philosophy, so that is going off piste.”
As regards new ageism you gave a platform for this lady, Becca Tarnas, in “Did Jung and Tolkien Enter the Same World?”July 31 2026, who is totally new age as the very subject gives away.
I wrote in the comments.
This is pure New Age mysticism. At the Philosophy, Cosmology, and Consciousness program at the California Institute of Integral Studies where she works the website states "The Ph.D. in Philosophy, Cosmology, and Consciousness offers a rigorous exploration of complex themes interlinking philosophy, cosmology, and consciousness studies. This program challenges students to investigate profound questions about the universe and the nature of human experience through an interdisciplinary approach. You'll engage with contemporary debates and contribute original research to this emerging field."
I am sure your work on science is excellent but I don’t understand any of it – in spite of the fact I studied maths at Cambridge University, England – quite a while ago. Positivism is the scientific method so that is fine.
You said in an interview you had not decided your philosophical position. Maybe that is why you stray into mysticism and new age.
You have watched my #CORE1 video and so if you want to "climb out of the positivist box" there are a few good starting points there.
I would urge you to watch the last section on the “FULCRUM PROBLEM”. That describes a fundamental issue with most philosophy (not science) which no one ever addresses. It totally destroys positivism as a philosophical method
Whether it's real or self-created, I've been chasing encounter for years. Looking for so-called thin places and trying to connect with what James calls the More. Section hikes on the Appalachian Trail that felt like church. Old churches on the Camino de Santiago. Sitting on the rocks at Columba's Bay on Iona trying to meditate while squirming and losing focus every thirty seconds.
But sometimes, in fits and starts, feeling overcome by presence.
I don't know if I think of myself as SBNR. Honestly I don't know what I'd call myself, and it seems to change depending on who's asking. Cultural Catholic? Contemplative cultural Christian? Still trying to figure this out.
I'm going down the rabbit hole on Luhrmann's work now, and I'm especially curious about the contemplative practice she said she's building for the SBNR crowd. Does anyone here know more about that?
Curt, I think there is another possibility hiding inside this discussion. Explaining the mechanism by which a person experiences an unseen intelligence does not necessarily tell us whether the experience is internally generated or whether that mechanism is the means by which a genuine relation becomes accessible.
Luhrmann’s work on absorption, attention, and the porous boundary between self and world therefore raises a fascinating question that I think deserves to remain open: Could some unusual experiences result from a state-dependent capacity to participate in a genuine external relationship, rather than merely from a state-dependent capacity to generate the experience of one?
Perhaps our mistake is assuming the phenomenon must reside entirely on one side or the other—either “out there” as an independently existing signal, or “in here” as a construction of the brain. There is a third possibility: the phenomenon may sometimes exist in the relation itself.
Music gives us an ordinary hint of this. A microphone can measure every frequency, yet the meaning, coherence, or transcendence of music is not located in any single sound wave. It emerges through the relationship between pattern, body, memory, attention, and listener.
If that possibility is taken seriously, altered or contemplative states become interesting not because they prove anything supernatural, but because they may change the conditions of relation. The scientific question then shifts from “Was the experience real?” to something much richer:
What becomes perceptible—or even possible—when the organization of the observer changes?
And eventually: Are there cases where something on the other side of that relationship changes too?
That last question seems to me where this becomes experimentally fascinating.
This immediately took me back to a rabbit hole I went down earlier this year around Occam’s Razor.
“The experience is real. But is God?”
Maybe we don’t have to answer the second question before we can investigate the first. A religious or mystical experience doesn’t need to be dismissed as “not real” simply because we can’t establish its external source. But equally, the reality of the experience doesn’t establish the explanation we attach to it.
Something happened. So what changed? What made that particular experience accessible, integrated and experientially real to that person?
That distinction has become increasingly important to me in thinking about consciousness: don’t use the mystery to explain the mystery. We don’t need to invoke mysticism to explain an experience we don’t yet understand… and we don’t need to explain the experience away, either.
Start with what we can observe. Strip away assumptions. Ask what structure and organisation made the experience possible. Occam’s Razor keeps turning up in interesting places.
Laden with the sadness of Mortal Man Doomed to Die, we all too soon join the masses of the Dead, the brief candle of consciousness snuffed out. It's absurd! So of course we must believe in some form of soul and some form of immortality, else we live out our lives in the dark shadow of Grief and Death. Science and Reason can give us no comfort, so, like children, we must seek comfort;
heaven that never was, always will be true.
The experience is real. And so is the physics.
Every major faith tradition independently arrived at the same answer to the deepest question: before the universe, there was nothing — and from that nothing, by an act of intelligence, everything emerged.
Physics spent the last century arriving at the same place from the opposite direction. Feynman, Hawking, Guth, Krauss — independent calculations, different decades, one result: the total energy of the universe is zero. Matter plus gravity equals nothing. The universe, taken as a whole, has the same value as the nothing that preceded it.
The experience of the divine and the equations of physics are not in conflict. They are converging on the same boundary — the one place physics reaches and stops: the uncaused first cause.
The Indeterminate Null framework is the first proposed mechanism that begins from absolute zero — no prior fields, no prior laws, no prior anything — and derives time, space, and matter through a single logical constraint. It makes the gap explicit. And it acknowledges honestly what lives in that gap.
Whether you call it God, the Tao, Brahman, or the null state — the physics agrees something was there.
Something from Nothing Pt. 5 — God and Physics Agree: The Universe from Nothing [link to video]
One of the notable aspects of discussions of “god” amongst positivist thinkers like Curt and his guest, Tanya Luhrmann, is that they never attempt to define what god is. If they were discussing, say, ethics, Aristotle, string theory, and so on, they would attempt at some stage, usually at the beginning, to define or at least describe the thing they were discussing. But god is different. The concept of god is taken as given and so everyone knows what they are talking about. This is very, very significant for what it tells us about atheism. The nearest this discussion comes to describing god is to say he is like a kiddy’s teddy bear. This is pop psychologism at its worse and should have no place in a serious discussion.
Even madcap atheists, like Harris and Dawkins, never say what god is but simply refute his existence without saying what they are refuting. But they must know somewhere in their minds what god is, and assume their audience has a similar understanding, to so emphatically claim to refute his existence. In this they are ahead of Christians, like me, who would never assume to understand god as well as these godless propagandists apparently do.
I will return to the understanding of god in a moment but let’s first look briefly at this discussion between Curt and Tanya Luhrmann. The title of the discussion is “The Experience Is Real. But Is God [real]?.” Luhrmann argues that people must work incredibly hard to make gods real. So the unstated assumption is that god is not real. She says “is real” and “feels real” are two different phenomena. “Is real” is that you have the propositional commitment. I believe that this tree is in front of me, I believe in God. “Feels real” is something more experiential.
The blurb to her book, How God Becomes Real, states “How do gods and spirits come to feel vividly real to people—as if they were standing right next to them? Humans tend to see supernatural agents everywhere, as the cognitive science of religion has shown. But it isn’t easy to maintain a sense that there are invisible spirits who care about you. In How God Becomes Real, acclaimed anthropologist and scholar of religion T. M. Luhrmann argues that people must work incredibly hard to make gods real.”
She is a psychologist as well as an anthropologist and here her anthropological researches lead her to the psychologist approach. What is psychologism? It is the use of psychology to explain behaviour and belief. This means a positivism explanation. In this, the individual is reduced for they are just performing according laid down models. Psychologism is usually attributed to J.S.Mill, the early nineteenth century philosophy. There was a strong reaction to this view in the early twentieth century but in today’s highly positivist intellectual landscape it has a natural fit.
There is a lot of talk of spirituality in this discussion with statistics telling us that a lot of people consider themselves to be spiritual but not religious. This is the closest we get to breeching the psychologist/positivist barrier with the associated admission that there is something beyond the material world.
But spiritual is never defined. It is merely linked to New Age and the “shift away from traditional faiths, and tolerance of other ways of thinking about the faith”, for instance, the Beatles taking up Maharishi yogi in the 1960s. There was a mishmash of ideas that emerged that came to be called the New Age. But this does not confront god. (It is a bit like Sam Harris claiming he already has been down the religion route with meditation, although it is amazing that someone who does meditation every day could remain impervious to anything beyond the material.)
The discussion here is entitled The Experience Is Real. But Is God [Real]? The second part is not really dealt with but the assumption is in the negative because “people must work incredibly hard to make gods real”. So they are a fabrication. However, the experience of god can be real just as the experience of anything real or imaginary can be real. I don’t think that is saying anything.
I would file Luhrmann’s ideas under Present Attacks on Religion. By saying it is constructed by humans she rejects religion. Once you are locked into positivism there is really no other way to go. The only way to look at it differently is through phenomenology which is diametrically opposed to positivism.
Phenomenology constructs quite a different reality where the viewer and world are not separated as positivism demands. In this you do not set up the question of god’s existence as a scientific matter to be cracked. That is considered meaningless – especially as we have seen positivists never attempt to define god. To put it briefly god is “given”, or in Martin Heidegger’s term “disclosed” (although he does not use this term in this context). God just is.
That positivists never attempt to define god affirms, unwittingly, the phenomenological view, for the lack of definition establishes firmly that god is given/disclosed without need for context or reference. The psychologism of Luhrmann is pretty much of a red herring. She writes detailed accounts of how humans in different cultures “construct” god but if god is given without compromise that it is not god that is being constructed. She is observing different cultures weaving different tapestries around an idea that is natural and undeniable to all humans
Curt, you say you read all the comments. Please comment here to confirm you have read this. And how about some feedback? Is this a discussion or what?
I'm not a positivist
Positivism is the appropriate method in science and mathematics which is what you mostly do. But it cannot apply to philosophy as philosophy can never produce scientific truth. If it could it would be science not philosophy. Positivist philosophy which appears to be the mainstream today seeks to apply the scientific positivist method to philosophy. This is disastrous and ultimately nihilistic. It is an impossible project producing endless discussion and papers to justify academic careers. I see you are unhappy with positivist but you try to climb out of the positivist box into mysticism and new ageism. These are the other side of the coin of positivism and not the way to go. Still, keep questioning. You may find your way. In my view that will not happen until you embrace phenomenology and life philosophy. Of course you have to start by understanding what those thing are. They are not really difficult except that our culture trains us in positivism as being the only way so getting there needs to be a leap of thought
Not quite sure why you're saying that I'm climbing into mysticism or new ageism.
I wrote that “you try to climb out of the positivist box into mysticism and new ageism.”.
To take mysticism first in This Is A Strange Post , Jul 07, 2026, you wrote
"Where I Side With the Mystics.
A theory of everything in the formal sense may turn out to be smaller than an account of Everything there is.
William James said there are some experiences that “defy expression.” Such states “must be directly experienced; it cannot be imparted or transferred to others.” It can’t be imparted whole, from within.
James heard that as words failing the mystic but it might just be the mystic being early. Why? Well, the fantasy that fails is the vantage point outside your own experience, and the mystics seem to have caught something quite before the logicians did. In fact, this happens more than you think. Washing hands tends to lead to stronger confessions.
As someone who petitions for precision by professional position, I also keep a place for mystery. James did as well. He said that if you lack the ear, you would rate the musician as “weak-minded or absurd,” and “the mystic finds that most of us accord to his experiences an equally incompetent treatment.”
I posted in my comment.
"But you do not need mysticism. That is always a cop out – an acknowledgement that you do not have the answer. And mysticism is NOT philosophy, so that is going off piste.”
As regards new ageism you gave a platform for this lady, Becca Tarnas, in “Did Jung and Tolkien Enter the Same World?”July 31 2026, who is totally new age as the very subject gives away.
I wrote in the comments.
This is pure New Age mysticism. At the Philosophy, Cosmology, and Consciousness program at the California Institute of Integral Studies where she works the website states "The Ph.D. in Philosophy, Cosmology, and Consciousness offers a rigorous exploration of complex themes interlinking philosophy, cosmology, and consciousness studies. This program challenges students to investigate profound questions about the universe and the nature of human experience through an interdisciplinary approach. You'll engage with contemporary debates and contribute original research to this emerging field."
I am sure your work on science is excellent but I don’t understand any of it – in spite of the fact I studied maths at Cambridge University, England – quite a while ago. Positivism is the scientific method so that is fine.
You said in an interview you had not decided your philosophical position. Maybe that is why you stray into mysticism and new age.
You have watched my #CORE1 video and so if you want to "climb out of the positivist box" there are a few good starting points there.
I would urge you to watch the last section on the “FULCRUM PROBLEM”. That describes a fundamental issue with most philosophy (not science) which no one ever addresses. It totally destroys positivism as a philosophical method
Whether it's real or self-created, I've been chasing encounter for years. Looking for so-called thin places and trying to connect with what James calls the More. Section hikes on the Appalachian Trail that felt like church. Old churches on the Camino de Santiago. Sitting on the rocks at Columba's Bay on Iona trying to meditate while squirming and losing focus every thirty seconds.
But sometimes, in fits and starts, feeling overcome by presence.
I don't know if I think of myself as SBNR. Honestly I don't know what I'd call myself, and it seems to change depending on who's asking. Cultural Catholic? Contemplative cultural Christian? Still trying to figure this out.
I'm going down the rabbit hole on Luhrmann's work now, and I'm especially curious about the contemplative practice she said she's building for the SBNR crowd. Does anyone here know more about that?
Religion is like a teddy bear. Both are a crutch, an escape from reality
My teddy was real! Grrr!
God is a simple thing to create: I simply anthropomorphize the universe as far as I can perceive it. Done!
People believe in the supernatural or a god because it soothes them and gives them comfort and hope.
Curt, I think there is another possibility hiding inside this discussion. Explaining the mechanism by which a person experiences an unseen intelligence does not necessarily tell us whether the experience is internally generated or whether that mechanism is the means by which a genuine relation becomes accessible.
Luhrmann’s work on absorption, attention, and the porous boundary between self and world therefore raises a fascinating question that I think deserves to remain open: Could some unusual experiences result from a state-dependent capacity to participate in a genuine external relationship, rather than merely from a state-dependent capacity to generate the experience of one?
Perhaps our mistake is assuming the phenomenon must reside entirely on one side or the other—either “out there” as an independently existing signal, or “in here” as a construction of the brain. There is a third possibility: the phenomenon may sometimes exist in the relation itself.
Music gives us an ordinary hint of this. A microphone can measure every frequency, yet the meaning, coherence, or transcendence of music is not located in any single sound wave. It emerges through the relationship between pattern, body, memory, attention, and listener.
If that possibility is taken seriously, altered or contemplative states become interesting not because they prove anything supernatural, but because they may change the conditions of relation. The scientific question then shifts from “Was the experience real?” to something much richer:
What becomes perceptible—or even possible—when the organization of the observer changes?
And eventually: Are there cases where something on the other side of that relationship changes too?
That last question seems to me where this becomes experimentally fascinating.
This immediately took me back to a rabbit hole I went down earlier this year around Occam’s Razor.
“The experience is real. But is God?”
Maybe we don’t have to answer the second question before we can investigate the first. A religious or mystical experience doesn’t need to be dismissed as “not real” simply because we can’t establish its external source. But equally, the reality of the experience doesn’t establish the explanation we attach to it.
Something happened. So what changed? What made that particular experience accessible, integrated and experientially real to that person?
That distinction has become increasingly important to me in thinking about consciousness: don’t use the mystery to explain the mystery. We don’t need to invoke mysticism to explain an experience we don’t yet understand… and we don’t need to explain the experience away, either.
Start with what we can observe. Strip away assumptions. Ask what structure and organisation made the experience possible. Occam’s Razor keeps turning up in interesting places.
I would suggest a discussion with David Bentley Hart as much more fruitful and intellectually demanding.
https://youtu.be/NEAgVvW9i10 I've spoken to David Bentley Hart here. Hope you enjoy
my God is same as Einstein's God, her3 is my take
take
https://www.romeolupascu.net/the-exoverse-hypothesis/
If by God we mean our connection to nature then yes it's real